The Indiana Publisher

December 22, 2011

Hoosier State Press Association - The Indiana Publisher

Issue link: https://www.ifoldsflip.com/i/50848

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 3 of 3

Page 4 December 22, 2011 Court weighs anonymity of Web posters T he Indiana Court of Appeals heard argu ments last week about how the law should balance between the First Amend ment right of anonymous speech and the right of a defamed person to protect his or her reputation from libel. The threejudge panel was presented the question when The Indianapolis Star appealed a trial court order to turn over identifying informa tion about an anonymous poster on its website. Jeff Miller, a former chief executive officer of Junior Achievement, has filed suit against more than a dozen individuals and entities for comments made about him in connection with his involve ment in a Junior Achieve ment of Central Indiana building project that went awry. The Hoosier State Press Association Foundation helped fund an amicus brief in support of The Indianapolis Star. The brief asks the court to create a process requiring a plaintiff to clear some hurdles before a judge would require that an anonymous poster be identified. The HSPA Foundation believes a plaintiff should show there is a legitimate libel question before a judge would consider any action revealing the anonymous poster. Otherwise, a person unhap py about what had been writ ten about him or her anony mously could seek to unmask the commenter without any evidence that the posts were libelous. Judges Ezra Friedlander, Nancy Vaidik and Carr Darden heard the arguments in the appeal on Dec. 12. The Star's attorney, Jan Carroll, an attorney with Barnes & Thornburg of Indian apolis, argued that the trial court order should be overturned because the post ing on the newspaper website should fall under the state's reporters' privilege statute (also known as reporters' shield law). HSPA Hotline These questions came from The News-Banner (Bluffton), Herald-Republican (Angola), News and Tribune (Jeffersonville) and a town official from Andrews, Ind.: A Q I received a "sub- poena duces tecum" from an attorney seeking copies of any and all articles pertaining to a recent shoot- ing death. It came from his office and was signed by him (not a judge). Am I ordered to do this? Am I obligated by law to gather all this information at my expense? You're not com pelled to meet his demand since it's not a judicial order, but don't ignore it. I suggest you determine a fair rate for time to collect the information requested, and then contact the attorney and say you're willing to com ply with the subpoena if he's willing to pay for the cost to collect the information. If the lawyer went through the court to make the request, there would be a provision for payment; so he should be willing to pay you without having to go through the court to order your coop eration. I think lawyers often try to get the information free figur ing most people will comply with an attorney's request without asking for compensa tion. via email? Or does it have to go through the U.S. Postal Service to meet requirements of the Open Door Law? Q A While the statute specifies that the public agency can give you notice by Is it OK to send annual requests to government agen- cies for notifica- tion of meetings mail, email or fax, the law says "deliver by Jan. 1 an annual written request" for the newspaper requirement to ask the public agency for notice. I'd mail or handdeliver the request to be safe. Last week the Q A Jeffersonville Re development Commission received and subse- quently voted on a proposal for archaeological work at an area park. The vote was taken during a public meeting, but the com- mission didn't want to give me a copy of the proposal, saying it contained confiden- tial information. I filed a written request, and the commission has since provided me with a redacted copy of the document. The officials justified the redaction by referring to IC 14-21-1-32. I've never heard of this exemption before. I recall the leg islative passage of this statute (see below). The concern raised was in revealing the location of archaeological sites because there are individuals who may attempt to plunder the sites in the middle of the night looking for antiqui ties that they can sell – and in the process potentially damage the site and prevent archeologists from learning more about the history of the location. You might want to ask whether the confidentiality falls under (b) or (a). If (a), they would have greater dis cretion to share information about the site, which would be of interest to the public. IC 14-21-1-32: Confiden tial archeological site information Sec. 32. (a) Subject to sub sections (b) and (c), the divi sion may keep reports and information concerning the location of historic and arche ological sites confidential if the director of the division determines that disclosure would likely: (1) risk harm to the historic or archeological site; (2) cause a significant inva sion of privacy; or (3) impede the use of a traditional religious site by practitioners. (b) The division may not disclose to the public reports and information required to be confidential under federal law. (c) If the director of the division determines that reports and information should be confidential under subsection (a), the director of the department, in consulta tion with the director of the division, shall determine who may have access to the confi dential reports and informa tion. Q A Is an email mes- sage considered written notice according to the Open Door Law? Yes, email notice to the media would be sufficient. The Open Door Law requirement for notice is found at IC 5141.55. IC 5141.55(b)(2) spells out the requirement that notice of meetings must be given to the media at least 48 hours in advance. (Weekends and holidays don't count toward the 48 hours.) The section says notice can be accomplished through U.S. mail, email or fax. Don't forget you also have to post notice. See IC 514 1.55(b)(1). Contact Steve Key, HSPA executive director and gen- eral counsel, with media law questions at skey@hspa.com or (317) 624-4427. SAVE THE DATE! Annual Meetings Feb. 16-17, 2012 Without publishing anything new, the Fayetteville Observer ad package created new, year-long revenue in just one week! Contact Advantage Newspaper Consultants today to learn more about creating NEW annual revenue with your existing core products. Fayetteville Observer's Platinum TV ad package exceeded revenue goal in less than a week! Ask us about our digital editions! 910-323-0349 | info@newspaperconsultants.com | www.newspaperconsultants.com end up with a much weaker shield law than it now has. Representing the amicus Key Points By Steve Key The three judges immedi ately jumped on that argu ment. They asked Carroll what she felt the legislature intended about protecting a source and whether she believed the shield law should protect against all defamation actions. Carroll remained steadfast that privilege is absolute. That argument is one I'm not comfortable with from a practical standpoint. As an absolute, it would allow a person to maliciously attack someone on a newspa per website without any recourse for the victim. Even if the appellate court agreed with the premise, I fear the state legislature would address the issue. If that happens, Indiana could brief, Paul Levy, an attorney with Public Citizen of Washington, D.C., argued that the concern was with the process a court should use when asked to reveal the identity of an anonymous speaker. Levy advocated what is known as the Dendrite test, which would require a libel plaintiff to prove that he or she would likely prevail in showing that comments were libelous. There is also a notice provision to ensure the anony mous poster knows someone is suing to identify him or her. Kevin Betz, an Indianapolis attorney representing Miller, argued that regular discovery rules – a less strenuous test than Dendrite – should apply. He said it would be onerous to require the plaintiff to clear a summary judgment hurdle prior to discovery. Vaidik responded that a lesser hurdle could have a chilling effect on speech and Access Continued from Page 1 sessions on public access laws. "This requires that the peo ple's business be transacted in an open way or the public will lose trust in government. "Most government offi cials already comply with the existing law, but there are an unfortunate few who huddle behind closed doors or refuse to release public records, and there has been little ability to penalize such actions," he said. "I sup port Senator Gard's public access legislation because it would encourage everyone who works in government to uphold the standards of openness and transparency that Hoosiers deserve." Under Gard's bill, public agency officers and managers could also be fined for failing to give proper public notice of a meeting, taking final action outside of a regular public meeting and partici pating in a secret ballot dur ing a meeting. Additionally, the legisla tion would allow Indiana questioned Betz about why a goodfaith test would not be appropriate. At the end of the hourlong hearing, my take was that the appellate panel will not agree to the proposition that the reporters' shield law should apply to all comments posted on newspaper websites. However, I believe the judg es will set out some sort of test for the validity of a libel case when it involves an effort to pierce the anonymity of a speaker protected by the First Amendment. The question is what test will they choose? The answer hopefully will take Indiana newspapers out of the quandary of either spending thousands of dollars to protect the First Amend ment rights of anonymous posters or turning the infor mation over to plaintiffs with out regard to the legitimacy of the case. Steve Key is executive director and general counsel for HSPA. residents to ask for email notification of public meet ings but permit government agencies to post such notice on their websites as an alter native. "In order to maintain an open, fair government, public records and meetings need to be readily accessible to all Hoosiers," Gard said. "Email communications are just another form of getting the needed information out there." HSPA is working with Speaker of the House Brian Bosma, RIndianapolis, to secure an author for a House version of S.B. 92. Currently, the only recourse for someone who has been denied access to a government meeting or pub lic documents is a civil law suit, and paying court fees often deters individuals from filing suit. A penalty that would have to be paid by the official who deliberately violates public access laws should serve as a deterrent to such behavior. "This bill is aimed at protecting people's right to know," Gard said.

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of The Indiana Publisher - December 22, 2011