South Gibson Star-Times

March 22, 2022

The South Gibson Star-Times serves the towns of Haubstadt, Owensville and Fort Branch.

Issue link: https://www.ifoldsflip.com/i/1462205

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 10 of 24

B-4 Opinion Tuesday, March 22, 2022 South Gibson Star-Times O N L I N E • S M A RT P H O N E • TA B L E T sgstartimes.com/edition Web, Smartphone, Tablet Streamline the Headline! 812-753-3553 • 203 S. McCreary St. Fort Branch, IN • ads@sgstartimes.com tigation into potential foreign interference during the 2016 election. In granting the committee's motion for summary judg- ment, Jackson held that the committee had standing to file the suit and that the case was justiciable, or appropriate for a court to decide, even though it involved a dispute between two branches of government. In so holding, she wrote: "Simply put, the primary take- away from 250 years of record- ed American history is that Presidents are not kings. … This means that they do not have subjects, bound by loy- alty or blood, whose destiny they are entitled to control." She added: "Today, this Court adds that this conclu- sion is inescapable precisely because compulsory appear- ance by dint of a subpoena is a legal construct, not a politi- cal one, and per the Constitu- tion, no one is above the law. That is to say, however busy or essential a presidential aide might be, and whatever their proximity to sensitive domes- tic and national-security proj- ects, the President does not have the power to excuse him or her from taking an action that the law requires." The Department of Justice had not argued that Trump was a king or above the law. These phrases, though, were frequently invoked by liberal politicians and pundits at the time to caricature the pres- ident and it is troubling that Jackson chose to parrot this unnecessarily inflammatory rhetoric. A three-judge D.C. Circuit panel reversed Jackson on the issues of standing and justicia- bility, but the D.C. Circuit sit- ting en banc (all active judg- es of the circuit, not just the panel, presided) reversed the original panel on the first is- sue, and the case settled be- fore the en banc court re- solved the second issue. As an appellate judge, Jack- son recently joined an opin- ion written by Judge Patricia Millett in Trump v. Thompson upholding a lower court deci- sion rejecting Trump's effort to block the release of docu- ments being held by the Na- tional Archives to the Jan. 6 committee after the Biden administration declined to assert executive privilege to block their release. The Su- preme Court refused to inter- vene, with only Justice Clar- ence Thomas dissenting. LABOR LAW CASES Jackson has issued several significant opinions in labor law cases that likely go a long way in explaining why liber- al groups like Demand Justice designated her as their pre- ferred nominee. She is clear- ly partial to labor unions and is highly skeptical, if not down- right hostile, to any attempt to limit their ability to union- ize or engage in collective bar- gaining. In Am. Fed'n of Gov't Emps., AFL -CIO v. Trump, Jackson ruled in favor of fed- eral labor unions challeng- ing three of Trump's execu- tive orders related to collec- tive bargaining rights. The executive orders limited the issues unions could bargain over, the amount of time la- bor union officials could spend with union members, and the rights of members to appeal disciplinary actions. Jackson concluded that those orders conflicted with the Federal Service La- bor-Management Relations Statute. A unanimous D.C. Circuit panel reversed her de- cision, holding that Jackson did not have subject-matter ju- risdiction and that such claims had to be pursued through the administrative process estab- lished under the Federal La- bor Relations Act. In a pair of written opinions in AFL -CIO v. NLRB, Jackson vacated (invalidated) a Nation- al Labor Relations Board rule that amended union election procedures to slow down the union election process. She concluded that the rule con- tained more than procedur- al rule changes and should have been subject to no- tice-and-comments rulemak- ing requirements in the Ad- ministrative Procedure Act. In AFL -CIO v. Federal La- bor Relations Authority, a group of public sector unions challenged a 2020 rule by the Federal Labor Relations Au- thority that raised the thresh- old for management-initiated changes to employment con- ditions that would trigger col- lective bargaining rights. In her first written major- ity opinion as a judge on the D.C. Circuit, Jackson invali- dated the rule, which raised the threshold from changes that had de minimis effect on a condition of employment to changes that had a substantial impact on a condition of em- ployment, concluding the au- thority's decision was insuffi- ciently reasoned and, there- fore, arbitrary and capricious in violation of the Administra- tive Procedure Act. Professor Jonathan Adler of the Case Western Reserve University School of Law de- scribed this opinion as "an er- roneous and unduly strict ap- plication" of applicable Su- preme Court precedent. IMMIGRATION CASES There is at least one high-profile case in which Jackson appeared to stretch the law—and was over- turned—to frustrate the Trump administration's ef- forts to rigorously enforce our nation's immigration laws. In Make the Road N.Y. v. McAleenan, immigration advocacy groups brought a pre-enforcement challenge to the Department of Home- land Security secretary's de- cision to expand the catego- ries of noncitizens that would be subject to expedited remov- al from the United States. Jackson entered a nation- wide preliminary injunction to prevent the revised rule from taking effect, concluding that she had jurisdiction to consid- er the case and that the plain- tiffs were likely to succeed on their claim that the agency's action was arbitrary and ca- pricious and therefore violat- ed the Administrative Proce- dure Act. In doing so, she wrote that the government's argument was "peculiar" and "reeks of bad faith, demonstrates con- tempt for the authority that the Constitution's Framers have vested in the judicial branch, and, ultimately, de- prives successful plaintiffs of the full measure of the reme- dy to which they are entitled." The D.C. Circuit reversed her injunction. The majori- ty opinion, written by fellow Obama appointee Millett, held that while the district court had jurisdiction to consid- er the matter, Congress had granted the secretary "sole and unreviewable discretion" on expedited removal deter- minations. Judge Neomi Rao dissent- ed, arguing that the district court lacked jurisdiction be- cause the Immigration and Nationality Act bars judicial review of the secretary's dis- cretionary decisions about ex- pedited removal. In Kiakombua v. Wolf, Jack- son ruled in favor of five non- citizens who were subject to expedited removal and against the Trump adminis- tration and held that chang- es made by U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, a subagency of the Department of Homeland Security, to its Credible Fear Lesson Plan utilized criteria that had not been prescribed by Congress in the Immigration and Na- tionality Act. Jackson vacated the revised rule and ordered that the plaintiffs be provided with a new asylum hearing us- ing lawful standards. In Center for Biological Di- versity v. McAleenan, envi- ronmental groups challenged the homeland security secre- tary's invocation of the Illegal Immigration Reform and Im- migrant Responsibility Act to waive certain environmental laws in order to expedite con- struction of a border wall in New Mexico. In contrast to her decision in Make the Road, Jackson granted the government's mo- tion to dismiss the case, con- cluding that the court lacked jurisdiction under the relevant statute to consider nonconsti- tutional challenges to such a decision. The Supreme Court declined to hear the case. Las Americas Immigrant Advocacy Center v. Wolf was another case in which Jackson sided with the government. In that case, several advocacy groups challenged the gov- ernment's policy of holding noncitizens in Customs and Border Protection facilities, which they claimed were in- humane, while awaiting asy- lum interviews. Jackson held that while the plaintiffs had standing to bring the case, the detention policy was a reasonable inter- pretation of the Immigration and Nationality Act and its im- plementing regulations. OTHER IMPORTANT ADMINISTRATIVE CASES In Policy and Research v. HHS and a companion case, Jackson ruled that Depart- ment of Health and Human Services' announcement that it was going to shorten the time period for grants for teen pregnancy prevention programs from five years to three years was arbitrary and capricious in violation of the Administrative Procedure Act because it was issued without notice or an adequate expla- nation. But some of Jackson's de- cisions—even those ruling against an agency—cannot be characterized as reflexive- ly liberal. For example, in Otay Mesa Property, L.P. v. Dep't of Interi- or, while agreeing that the En- dangered Species Act would allow the Interior Department to protect fairy shrimp in ver- nal pools that were "occupied" by them, Jackson agreed with the plaintiff that the agency's designation of the land and water between the pools—a total of 56 acres—as critical habitat for the species was "manifestly unreasonable." RACIAL PREFERENCES In Rothe Dev., Inc. v. Dep't of Def., Jackson rejected the plaintiff's constitutional chal- lenge to Section 8(a) of the Small Business Administra- tion Act, which establishes a program of preferential treat- ment in government contract- ing for businesses owned by "socially disadvantaged indi- viduals," concluding that the program satisfied strict scru- tiny. The D.C. Circuit (over a partial dissent) affirmed her judgment, albeit on different grounds, and the Supreme Court declined to consider the case. Another important line of questions in this area will not involve a case in which she is- sued an opinion, but two im- portant consolidated cases that the Supreme Court will hear next term. In Students for Fair Admis- sion v. President & Fellows of Harvard College and Students for Fair Admission v. Universi- ty of North Carolina, the jus- tices will reconsider whether racial preferences in college admissions are constitutional. In both cases, the admis- sions policies make it signifi- cantly more likely that black applicants will be admitted— and significantly less likely that Asian American appli- cants will be admitted—than other similarly qualified appli- cants. Jackson will be asked whether she will commit to re- cuse herself from taking part in the consideration of those cases. This is a legitimate question. While Jackson was not involved in the disposition of either of these cases as they wended their way through the lower courts, she has been a member of the Harvard Board of Overseers since 2016. As Ed Whelan, a senior fel- low and former president of the Ethics and Public Policy Center, has noted, this is not a ministerial position. The board, which meets multiple times a year, "provides coun- sel to the University's leader- ship on priorities, plans, and strategic initiatives." It is hard to imagine that the ongoing lawsuit challeng- ing Harvard's admission's pol- icy was not the subject of in- tense discussion among the board and the university's leadership. And interestingly, in her submitted questionnaire on pages 121 and 122, Jackson states that she recused her- self in a couple of cases that bear a striking resemblance to this situation. She recused herself in Doe v. Lhamon "because the com- plaint challenged the Depart- ment of Education's sexual as- sault guidelines for colleges and universities, and at the time that the matter was as- signed to me, I was serving on the board of a university that was evaluating its own poten- tial response to those guide- lines." Is there any doubt that she was referring to Harvard? And she recused herself in Chenari v. George Washing- ton University "because the plaintiff alleged that George Washington University im- properly terminated his en- rollment at the school for honor code violations, and at the time this matter came be- fore me, I was affiliated with George Washington Univer- sity Law School as an adjunct professor." Suffice it to say that being on the board of overseers of a university is a much more se- rious "affiliation" than being an adjunct professor. CONCLUSION These are just a few of the opinions that are likely to be scrutinized by senators during the coming hearing that should yield insights as to how Jackson decides cas- es and whether she does so in an impartial manner, focusing exclusively on the law and not her personal or political pre- dilections. Senators should ask tough and probing questions of Jack- son in order to learn more about her judicial philosophy and approach to resolving le- gal disputes, both of which are vital considerations as they de- cide whether to confirm her to the high court. John Malcolm is Vice Pres- ident for the Institute for Con- stitutional Government and Di- rector of the Meese Center for Legal & Judicial Studies. JUSTICE Continued from page 3 who might get a better pay- check." I push back. "President Biden would say, 'We have to go there just to deter Russia. If we don't, we're inviting them to invade other countries.'" We shouldn't let govern- ment scare us into going to war, says Paul. "Fear is the tool of totalitarians." Paul's an- ti-war arguments have shift- ed public opinion. Today we might be fighting in Ukraine if it were not for Ron Paul and his warnings about the risk of America policing the world. John Stossel is creator of Stos- sel TV and author of "Give Me a Break: How I Exposed Huck- sters, Cheats, and Scam Artists and Became the Scourge of the Liberal Media." POLITICIAN Continued from page 3

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of South Gibson Star-Times - March 22, 2022