The South Gibson Star-Times serves the towns of Haubstadt, Owensville and Fort Branch.
Issue link: https://www.ifoldsflip.com/i/789213
B-10 Tuesday, Februar y 21, 2017 South Gibson Star-Times Minority View by Walter E. Williams The Weekly by Jill Heuring Pawns of Liberals Adventurous Continued on page 11 Continued on page 11 Heritage Viewpoint by Edwin J. Feulner Marriage penalty tax should be deleted A Valentine's Day present from the federal government? It could happen. No, I'm not talking about flowers or candy. I'm talking about getting rid of the "marriage penal- ty" that's built into one of our big- gest welfare programs. That program is the Earned In- come Tax Credit. The EITC is the nation's second largest means-test- ed cash welfare program. EITC — unlike other welfare programs — is structured to give incentives to work. But reforms are needed to help it better achieve that purpose — and to ensure that it doesn't dis- courage marriage. EITC provides "refundable" tax credits to low-income individuals. What's a "refundable tax credit," you may ask? It's simply a cash welfare grant to individuals who have no federal income tax liabil- ity. Historically, around two-thirds of the families with children re- ceiving the EITC are single par- ents, and one-third are married couples, according to welfare ex- pert Robert Rector. The average value of an EITC payment to a fam- ily with children was $2,919. Now, there are several problems with the EITC program that need to be addressed. Fraud is rampant, for one thing. Erroneous over- claims account for at least a quar- ter of the $59 billion in annual EI- TC spending. Another problem is how EITC benefits can go to nonparents. Grandparents, aunts, uncles, and older siblings and stepsiblings can often claim EITC cash bonuses for children. As Mr. Rector points out, this leads to "benefit shop- ping," arbitrarily as- signing children for EITC purposes to rel- atives whose earnings will elicit the highest EITC payment. Tax- payers wind up pay- ing more, and the EI- TC work incentive is dodged. But let's focus for now on how the EI- TC discriminates against mar- ried couples. In most cases, the EITC benefits received by un- married parents who cohabit are significantly higher than those re- ceived by similar couples who are married. To understand why, consider a father and mother who each earn $20,000 per year and have two chil- dren. If they simply live together, each parent will file a separate in- come tax return, and their income will be maximized if each parent claims one child for tax purposes. They won't pay any income tax, but will receive a combined $7,269 in refundable tax credits through the EITC and the Additional Child Tax Credit, or ACTC. But if they marry, it's a differ- ent story. They still pay no feder- al income tax, but their refundable tax credits are cut from $7,269 to $2,960, a loss of $4,308. Just get- ting married forces this couple to give up about one-tenth of their in- come. And let's not forget that the cohabiting couple is likely getting other benefits as well, such as food stamps, which aren't available to the married couple. This disincentive to marriage is not only unwise, but perverse. "Research consistent- ly demonstrates that married adults are physically and emo- tionally healthier than nonmarried adults; they are also more eco- nomically secure," Mr. Rector writes. "Family structure is also the most import- ant factor in predicting upward so- cial mobility of children, and chil- dren with two parents do best." How much better do they do? When looking at families with the same race and same parental edu- cation, we find that, compared to intact married families, children from single-parent homes are: • More than twice as likely to be arrested for a juvenile crime. • Twice as likely to be treated for emotional and behavioral prob- lems. • Roughly twice as likely to be suspended or expelled from school. • A third more likely to drop out before completing high school. There's a lot to fix in the EITC pro- gram, and one of the most important is eliminating its marriage penalty. It may not seem very romantic, but increasing EITC benefits for mar- ried couples with children is one of the best Valentine Day's presents Uncle Sam could give. Ed Feulner is founder of the Her- itage Foundation (heritage.org). Ordinary black people can- not afford to go along with the liberal agenda that calls for un- dermining police authority. That agenda makes for more black crime victims. Let's look at what works and what doesn't work. In 1990, New York City ad- opted the practice in which its police officers might stop and question a pedestrian. If there was suspicion, they would frisk the person for weapons and oth- er contraband. This practice, well within the law, is known as a Terry stop. A fter two decades of this proactive police program, New York City's homicides fell from over 2,200 per year to about 300. Blacks were the ma- jor beneficiaries of proactive po- licing. According to Manhattan Institute scholar Heather Mac Donald—author of "The War on Cops"—seeing as black males are the majority of New York City's homicide victims, more than 10,000 blacks are alive to- day who would not be had it not been for proactive policing. The American Civil Liberties Union and other leftist groups brought suit against proactive policing. A U.S. District Court judge ruled that New York City's "stop and frisk" policy vi- olated the 14th Amendment's promise of equal protection be- cause black and Hispanic peo- ple were subject to stops and searches at a higher rate than whites. But the higher rate was justified. Mac Donald points out that while blacks are 23 percent of New York City's population, they are responsible for 75 per- cent of shootings and 70 percent of robberies. Whites are 34 per- cent of the population of New York City. They are responsible for less than 2 percent of shoot- ings and 4 percent of robberies. If you're trying to prevent shoot- ings and robberies, whom are you going to focus most atten- tion on, blacks or whites? In 2015, 986 people were shot and killed by police. Of that num- ber, 495 were white (50 percent), and 258 were black (26 percent). Liberals portray shootings by police as racist attacks on blacks. To solve this problem, they want police departments to hire more black police officers. It turns out that the U.S. Justice Department has found that black police offi- cers in San Francisco and Phila- delphia are likelier than whites to shoot and use force against black suspects. That finding is consis- tent with a study of 2,699 fatal police killings between 2013 and 2015, conducted by John R. Lott Jr. and Carlisle E. Moody of the Crime Prevention Research Cen- ter, showing that the odds of a black suspect's being killed by a black police officer were con- sistently greater than the odds of a black suspect's being killed by a white officer. And little is said about cops killed. Mac Donald reports that in 2013, 42 percent of cop killers were black. Academic liberals and civil rights spokespeople make the claim that the disproportionate number of blacks in prison is a result of racism. They ignore the fact that black criminal ac- tivity is many multiples of that of other racial groups. They ar- gue that differential imprison- ment of blacks is a result of the racist war on drugs. Mac Donald says that state prisons contain 88 percent of the nation's pris- on population. Just 4 percent of state prisoners are incarcerat- ed for drug possession. She ar- gues that if drug offenders were removed from the nation's pris- ons, the black incarceration rate would go down from about 37.6 percent to 37.4 percent. The vast majority of blacks in prison are there because of violent crime— and mostly against black people. That brings us to the most tragic aspect of black crime. The primary victims are law-abiding black people who must conduct their lives in fear. Some par- ents serve their children meals on the floor and sometimes put them to sleep in bathtubs so as to avoid stray bullets. The av- erage American does not live this way and would not tolerate it. And that includes the white liberals who support and make excuses for criminals. Plain de- Pursuit of the Cure by Star Parker Democrats impede excellence in education What is it about new Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos that so bothers Democrats that not a sin- gle Democratic Senator voted to confirm her, requiring Vice Pres- ident Mike Pence to cast the de- ciding vote? You would think, after years of Washington pumping tens of bil- lions of taxpayer funds into pub- lic education with virtually no im- provement in test scores, a new Ed- ucation secretary that genuinely wants change would be celebrated. Programme for International Student Assessment tests adminis- tered by the Organisation for Eco- nomic Co-operation and Develop- ment, an organization of 34 of the largest industrialized nations in the world, showed that American 15 -year-olds finish only slightly above average in science, and they perform below average in reading and math. This is despite the U.S. spend- ing 31 percent more per student for elementary and secondary ed- ucation than the average of these 34 nations. Secretary DeVos is an advocate of opening the public school sys- tem to competition and new ideas. Commitment to these principles of freedom and competition touch the essence of American excep- tionalism. Anyone who claims to care about excellence yet supports govern- ment monopoly and opposes com- petition is not being honest with themselves, with others, or both. And this, sadly, summarizes what is going on with Democrats and education. It's about politics, power and interests—not about ex- cellence. And here we must note the perverse influence of teach- ers unions. According to the Center for Responsive Politics, the teach- ers unions are among the larg- est political spend- ers in the nation. Of 20,000 organizations surveyed, the Nation- al Education Associ- ation and the Amer- ican Federation of Teachers combined were second in the nation in total polit- ical contributions since 1989 - - $212 million. And overwhelmingly these contributions are to Democrats. In 2016, 92 percent of the contri- butions of the two unions went to Democrats. Two prominent Democrat Sen- ators: Cory Booker from New Jer- sey and Elizabeth Warren from Massachusetts, are both on re- cord in previous years, before be- ing elected to the Senate, support- ing parental choice in education. Yet both, after getting elected to the Senate, and both with presi- dential ambitions, have somehow changed their minds on this crit- ical issue and both voted against DeVos's confirmation. Booker, while mayor of New- ark, New Jersey, in 2012, gave the keynote address for Betsy DeVos's organization American Federation for Children, and spoke passion- ately for parental choice. A few days after being con- firmed, DeVos attended an event at Jefferson Middle School Acad- emy in Washington, D.C. Protes- tors greeted her and blocked her entrance to the school. The protest was encouraged on Twitter by president of the Wash- ington Teachers' Union Elizabeth Davis, who said, "We want to share the message that we love our pub- lic school system." Teachers may love their public school system, but they certainly don't love the children in it trying to get an education. According to a study by WalletHub, the D.C. public school system, despite ranking 13th in the nation in spend- ing, ranks 47 out of 51 in performance. It ranks worst in the nation in dropout rates, math scores, read- ing scores and SAT scores. Sixty-four percent of children in the D.C. public school system are black and 18 percent are Hispanic. In a Gallup poll published last August, 28 percent of parents with their oldest child in a public school said they were "completely satis- fied" with the education their child is getting. This compared with 62 percent whose child is in private school saying they are "complete- ly satisfied." The 62 percent sat- isfaction with private school was the same for high-income parents and for medium- and low-income parents. There is a reason why more than a million children are on waiting lists to enter charter schools na- tionwide and why studies show that parental choice produces pos- itive results. Yet teachers unions and the ma- ny with allegiances to the Dem- ocratic Party fight to keep the government monopoly of public schools. Fighting for their own selfish interests, they hurt Amer- ica's children and our nation's fu- ture. Star Parker is an author and president of CURE, Center for Ur- ban Renewal and Education. I came to a surprising conclu- sion a couple weeks ago – I'm ad- venturous. I'd never considered that before. Normally, if you asked me to de- scribe myself, I'd start with intelli- gent, or caring, or maybe even vol- atile depending on the day. But I realize now that adventurous is the word for me. I'm always wanting to try new things. Some exploits are more productive than others. For ex- ample, at least once a week I feel like taking up smoking, but I ig- nore that whim. I also consider a tattoo or new piercing or hair col- or at least once a month. Perhaps more beneficial has been my efforts to exercise in var- ious, adventurous ways. My cous- in got me into rock climbing, and I, in turn, have been dragging every- one and their brother to Vertical Excape in Evansville to climb with me. It's a fantastic way to be active: you're working out pretty much your whole body, you don't have to be super strong to be good at it, and it's also a mental challenge as much as a physical one. It's incred- ibly exhilarating and worthwhile. I also started a Couch-to-5k pro- gram to get me running, some- thing I never thought I'd be inter- ested in or capable of. This pro- gram uses interval training to build up your running chops, so instead of just trying to jog for 30 minutes on your first day out, you start with a brisk walking warm- up, followed by 30 seconds of jog- Guest Column by Rep. Tom Washburne (R-Evansville) The work you seldom see A reasonably informed person probably reads the newspaper (certainly the Star-Times!), catch- es some news through radio and T V and perhaps has a website or magazine they turn to frequently. But even such a person likely has little knowledge as to what is actu- ally going on in their state govern- ment beyond the major initiatives like infrastructure and education. Let me give you just one exam- ple. I happen to serve as chair of the Indiana House Committee on Courts and Criminal Code. As I write this column, I have beside me a stack of bills that the committee will be consider- ing, along with amendments that have been filed for the commit- tee to address. Here is the bill list: HB 1064 Habitual Offender Requirements; HB 1148 Canna- bidiol; HB 1209 Organized Retail Theft; HB 1218 Juvenile Justice; HB 1312 Pharmacy Robbery; HB 1405 Public Defense Reimburse- ments; and, HB 1513 Crimes In- volving Adoption. This is a large list, but given the committee has 73 bills assigned to it and only un- til Feb. 21 to get its reports to the full House, it is also an important list. It is also a list that will like- ly take members several hours to examine, as every bill will have a presentation, public testimony, possible amendments and at least one roll call vote. These bills originate from prosecutors, public defenders, concerned businesses, mem- bers of the public and members of the legislature themselves. All of them affect people and in- volve vital issues, but it is possi- ble that the passage of many of these bills (when and if they get that far) will never enjoy much coverage in our media. I am cer- tainly not intending here to crit- icize this lack of attention. I am well aware that other House and Senate committees are working their way through a large vari- ety of bills. Indeed, there are 24 standing committee in the House, so while not all of these commit- Continued on page 11

