South Gibson Star-Times

February 14, 2017

The South Gibson Star-Times serves the towns of Haubstadt, Owensville and Fort Branch.

Issue link: https://www.ifoldsflip.com/i/786306

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 20 of 22

B-8 Tuesday, Februar y 14, 2017 South Gibson Star-Times Minority View by Walter E. Williams The Weekly by Jill Heuring Minimum wage and discrimination One, two, five projects at a time Continued on page 9 Heritage Viewpoint by Edwin J. Feulner Overregulation drags down business "If I could paraphrase a well- known statement by Will Rogers that he never met a man he didn't like," President Reagan once quipped, "I'm afraid we have some people around here who never met a tax they didn't like." Instead of "tax," he could just as easily have said "regulation." Consider the reaction to our new president's determination to cut regulations by 75 percent. "Trump's unpopular deregulation agenda will permit corporations to rip off consumers, poison our envi- ronment, cheat and mistreat work- ers, and more," wrote Public Citi- zen, a liberal nonprofit group, pre- dicting "disastrous consequences" would follow. They and other pro-regulation groups often accuse conservatives of counting only the costs of reg- ulations and none of the benefits. This charge might resonate a bit more if they didn't do the oppo- site and act as if cost wasn't even an issue. Unfortunately, our economy is awash in regulations. "There is vir- tually no aspect of our lives over which laws and ordinances do not reign," regulation expert Diane Katz writes. "Congress and fed- eral bureaucrats routinely ignore regulatory costs, exaggerate bene- fits, and breach legislative and con- stitutional boundaries." According to independent esti- mates, regulation costs us more than $2 trillion annually. Yes, "tril- lion" with a "t" — 12 zeroes. That's more money than the Internal Rev- enue Service collects in income taxes each year. In just the past eight years, the Obama adminis- tration issued more than 22,700 rules, with just the biggest ones increasing the annual regulatory costs by some $120 billion. Add in the regula- tory burdens imposed during the last Bush administration, and the annual cost of red tape has increased by at least $200 billion in the past 15 years. The cost to taxpay- ers of government ad- ministering all that red tape is high. Fis- cal 2017 figures put it at $70 billion, an amount that has almost doubled since 2000. Much of that increase is what we pay the regulators, all 279,000 of them. Put another way, we're paying regulators plenty to enforce regu- lations that cost us more than ever. With good reason did President Trump say that his deregulation agenda is intended to "remove the anchor that's weighing us down." That anchor has been grow- ing for a long time. Prior to World War II, notes Washington Post col- umnist Robert Samuelson, regu- lations were confined mainly to a few large industries, such as rail- roads, banks, and the electric and phone utilities. "Now regulation is pervasive," he writes. "It touches air and water pollution, pensions, vehicle fuel ef- ficiency, the internet ('net neutral- ity' rules), home mortgages, politi- cal campaign contributions … and much more." And there's no end in sight. As the Competitive Enterprise points out, in fiscal 2015, the Federal Reg- ister (which lists final and recom- mended rules) totaled 80,260 pag- es. Given not only the size of the regulatory state, but the exponen- tial pace of its growth, who can really blame the pres- ident for wanting to cut regulation "mas- sively"? And, as Ms. Katz points out, the problem goes beyond the num- ber and cost of regula- tion. The problem also lies with the approach. "Conventional wis- dom has long held that government controls of in- dustry are the best and only way to protect the public," she writes. "We now know better. Forty years of command-and-control regimes have led to massive, ineffective, and unaccountable bureaucra- cies." There are several steps the Trump administration can take. One is to rescind the numerous ex- ecutive orders President Obama is- sued to sidestep Congress, espe- cially on labor, immigration and environmental issues. Another is to review all pending litigation and designate cases for settlement, including challenges to President Obama's Clean Pow- er Plan, his transgender bathroom directive, and the Environmental Protection Agency's egregious wa- ters of the U.S. rule, which affects property rights. "If you have 10,000 regulations, you destroy all respect for the law," Winston Churchill once said. Well, we have a lot more than 10,000 these days. It's high time we re- stored respect for the law — and began taming our out-of-control regulatory state. Ed Feulner is founder of the Her- itage Foundation (heritage.org). There is little question in most academic research that increases in the minimum wage lead to in- creases in unemployment. The de- batable issue is the magnitude of the increase. An issue not often in- cluded in minimum wage debates is the substitution effects of mini- mum wage increases. The substitu- tion effect might explain why Busi- ness for a Fair Minimum Wage, a national network of business own- ers and executives, argues for higher minimum wages. Let's look at substitution effects in general. When the price of anything ris- es, people seek substitutes and measures to economize. When gasoline prices rise, people seek to economize on the usage of gas by buying smaller cars. If the price of sugar rises, people seek cheap- er sugar substitutes. If prices of goods in one store rise, people search for other stores. This last example helps explain why some businessmen support higher min- imum wages. If they could impose higher labor costs on their less ef- ficient competition, it might help drive them out of business. That would enable firms that survive to charge higher prices and earn greater profits. There's a more insidious substi- tution effect of higher minimum wages. You see it by putting your- self in the place of a businessman who has to pay at least the mini- mum wage to anyone he hires. Say that you are hiring typists. There are some who can type 40 words per minute and others, equal in every other respect, who can type 80 words per minute. Whom would you hire? I'm guessing you'd hire the more highly skilled. Thus, one effect of the minimum wage is discrimination against the em- ployment of lower-skilled work- ers. In some places, the mini- mum wage is $15 an hour. But if a lower-skilled worker could offer to work for, say, $ 8 an hour, you might hire him. In addition to dis- crimination against lower-skilled workers, the minimum wage de- nies them the chance of sharpen- ing their skills and ultimately earn- ing higher wages. The most effec- tive form of training for most of us is on-the-job training. An even more insidious sub- stitution effect of minimum wag- es can be seen from a few quota- tions. During South A frica's apart- heid era, racist unions, which would never accept a black mem- ber, were the major supporters of minimum wages for blacks. In 1925, the South A frican Economic and Wage Commission said, "The method would be to fix a minimum rate for an occupation or craft so high that no Native would be like- ly to be employed." Gert Beet- ge, secretary of the racist Build- ing Workers' Union, complained, "There is no job reservation left in the building industry, and in the circumstances, I support the rate for the job (minimum wage) as the second-best way of protect- ing our white artisans." "Equal pay for equal work" became the rallying slogan of the South A fri- can white labor movement. These laborers knew that if employers were forced to pay black workers the same wages as white workers, there'd be reduced incentive to hire blacks. South A fricans were not alone in their minimum wage conspiracy against blacks. A fter a bitter 1909 strike by the Brotherhood of Loco- motive Firemen and Enginemen in the U.S., an arbitration board de- creed that blacks and whites were to be paid equal wages. Union members expressed their delight, saying, "If this course of action is followed by the company and the incentive for employing the Negro thus removed, the strike will not have been in vain." Our nation's first minimum wage law, the Davis-Bacon Act of 1931, had racist motivation. During its legislative debate, its congressional supporters made such statements as, "That contrac- tor has cheap colored labor that he transports, and he puts them in cabins, and it is labor of that sort that is in competition with white labor throughout the country." During hearings, American Fed- eration of Labor President William Green complained, "Colored labor We've been giving it to South Gibson and the surrounding counties for a long time, why not share what news you have with others? NEWS! 812-753-3553 South Gibson Pursuit of the Cure by Star Parker Trump's mistaken interest in HBCUs According to press reports, the topic of Historically Black Col- leges and Universities came up in the recent "listening session" at the White House with Presi- dent Trump and his internal team of black leaders, as part of Black History Month. Reportedly, this piqued the pres- ident's interest and the discussion continued after the meeting for- mally concluded, with presiden- tial aide Omarosa Manigault an- nouncing to the media that she is working on an executive order to help the HBCUs. This has apparently excited oth- er Republicans as an opportunity to show their interest in helping blacks and a meeting is reported- ly in the making between Republi- can congressional leaders, White House operatives and leaders from the HBCUs. The details of the executive or- der remain unknown. But short of it being a purely ceremonial tooth- less statement of support, it is rea- sonable to assume that it's about government money—that is usu- ally what interests HBCUs. Historically Black Colleges and Universities have a distinguished history, and they have played a very important role in black life, particularly during the years of segregation. But the question today is how does more government money go- ing into these institutions help fur- ther President Trump's promise to fix our inner cities? Pell Grants, which are outright grants from the federal govern- ment to low-income students, are of particular interest to HBCUs. They were upset with Barack Obama because in 2011 standards for Pell Grants were tightened and they claim this caused drops in HB- CU enrollment. But their enroll- ments were drop- ping before 2011. In 1976, 18 percent of all black students were enrolled in these in- stitutions. By 2013 it was down to 8 per- cent, meaning 92 per- cent of black students were attend- ing other colleges and universities. And overall black enrollment in institutions of higher learning is up. From 2000 to 2014, according to the National Center for Education Statistics, the percentage of black students among all students en- rolled in degree granting institu- tions rose from 11.7 percent to 14.5 percent. And enrollment of black students in the age range of 18 -25 stayed constant. According to a 2015 report from the think tank Demos, de- spite receiving a Pell Grant, these same students wind up taking on more debt. The study reports that among black and low-income stu- dents, 81 percent who received a Pell Grant graduated with debt compared to 46 percent who did not receive a Pell Grant. Nationwide, according to the National Center for Education Sta- tistics, 59 percent of all first-time college enrollees graduate in six years. For black students, it is 39.5 percent. But in HBCUs only 36 per- cent of students enrolled in four- year degree-granting institutions graduate in six years. So why is President Trump, who delivered a strong message in his campaign about work- ing for real change to build prosperity in poor black communi- ties, starting off by fo- cusing on more of what has hurt black advance- ment so much—poli- ticians showing them they care by spending government money? Perhaps part of the president's Black History Month listening tour should include a lesson in the damage govern- ment dependency has already do- ne in black communities, in order to start considering ways to pro- mote market based solutions to fight poverty and crime. President Trump has made some great appointments with great promise in this direction. Betsy DeVos at Education can start pushing for parental choice. Ben Carson at HUD should push for more freedom in low-income housing programs, such as stipu- lation-free housing vouchers, giv- ing recipients full control where to live. And Tom Price at HHS should push for transforming federal wel- fare expenditures into state block grants, giving more local control, and for market-based reforms in health care. Let's hope this is where Pres- ident Trump focuses his atten- tion, rather than getting divert- ed, as many Republicans in the past have, into thinking the way to show blacks Republicans care is to spend government money like Democrats. When I was young(er), I partic- ipated in 4-H. Starting out, my sis- ter and I were strongly encouraged to do the cooking and crafting projects. As I got older, I sneered at them in favor of creative writ- ing and photography, but as I've gotten even older, I've embraced those hobbies again (along with creative writing and photography). Last year, I picked up cross stitching. Now my mother-in-law is helping me get into quilting, which I've gotten into perhaps more quickly than she had hoped. I've even tried making wreaths for my door, though with little success, if I'm being honest. I really have no clue what I'm doing on that front. All this means I've fallen into a very common trap for crafters, and I'm sure all my fellow crafting ladies and gentlemen are already nodding their heads and grinning at my plight. My skills can't keep up with my ideas, and I have way too many projects started. On the one hand, it feels like having a huge personal library that you'll never be able to read all of in your lifetime. An enjoyable challenge, albeit insurmountable. On the other hand, it feels over- whelming at times, and I feel like I'm wasting time if I'm not work- ing on one project or another be- cause there are JUST SO MANY. Currently in progress, I have a photo-realistic cat cross stitch, a sampler cross stitch for Flan- nery's room, a set of cross stitch quilt blocks, my mom's birthday present from last year and Al- den's Valentine's Day cross stitch, not to mention the many projects I have finished stitching but nev- er gotten around to framing. My mother-in-law and I have one quilt in progress, but I've already start- ed acquiring materials for the next one. I don't even have my own sew- ing machine, people! I see you chuckling, fellow craft- er. I'm back on Pinterest, too, pin- ning everything from free cross stitch charts to how to make a quilted bib. Flannery hates bibs, but here I am, thinking about mak- ing her a bib. But thinking about new proj- ects – what it'll be, how I'll make it, what materials I need – is such a rush. Part of why I love crafting is that I thrive on creative hobbies; my mind is always moving, and it's important for me to have an outlet for that. The project brainstorm- ing gives me that outlet, but then I get ahead of myself and start a new project before finishing the old one. It's a common pitfall, of any hob- by, really, but especially creative ones. Think of all the writers who have countless unfinished stories in countless unfinished notebooks, all the painters with stacks of can- vases filling their studios, and yes, all the crafters with a seemingly infinite number of projects. For some people, that would be im- possible to enjoy. For people like me, it's delightful. I've fallen head first into the crafting black hole, and I'm float- ing among the endless fabrics and flosses in complete bliss. Jill Heuring is a young mom writ- ing and crafting her way through this stage of life. She lives with her husband, Alden, and daughter, Flannery, in Petersburg. Contact her at jill.heuring@gmail.com.

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of South Gibson Star-Times - February 14, 2017