The South Gibson Star-Times serves the towns of Haubstadt, Owensville and Fort Branch.
Issue link: https://www.ifoldsflip.com/i/1494926
Heritage Viewpoint By Robert E. Moffit, Ph.D. Key questions for new House subcommittee on Coronavirus pandemic It's no longer a "conspiracy theor y." There's growing evidence that COVID-19 probably originated in a lab in Wuhan, China, and not from a viral transmission from an animal to a human in nature. The Wall Street Journal reports, based on the most recent intelligence, such is the considered judgment of senior analysts at the U.S. Department of Energy, as well as at the FBI. If true, that Chinese lab leak unleashed a deadly global pandemic that killed nearly 7 million people, including more than 1.1 million Amer- icans. Communist Chinese officials insisted the pandemic originated in "nature." Their stubborn refusal to cooperate with international research teams to provide relevant information has hindered the production of definitive evidence concerning the pandemic's origins. Beijing has instead perpet- uated conflict and division within scientific and govern- mental circles in the West. In Februar y 2020, the World Health Organization, which faced restricted access to the Wuhan lab, nonetheless concluded that the coronavi- rus had a natural origin. In 2021, President Joe Biden's Office of National Intelli- gence report on the pandem- ic's origins was inconclusive. Among scientists, the debate on the origins remains unre- solved. Given the pandemic's massive death and economic destruction (an estimated $10 trillion), Congress must pursue an inquir y into COVID-19's origins. As diffi- cult as it will prove to be, that probe must be aggressive and deep. Congress must not only determine what federal officials knew, and when they knew what they knew, but also correct any deficiencies in America's response to prepare for the next public health crisis. As analysts with the Government Account- ability Office obser ve, "This understanding could help inform preparation and response to future epidemics and pandemics." The Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic of the House of Representa- tives, chaired by Rep. Brad Wenstrup, R-Ohio, will soon hold its first public hearings on the topic. The subcommit- tee should not only summon Energy Department and FBI analysts to testify on their recent assessments, but also officials of the State Depart- ment who issued a similar assessment of the origins of COVID-19 during the early stages of the pandemic in April 2020. Examining five potential scenarios, State Department officials then concluded, "There is no direct, smoking gun evidence to prove that a leak from Wuhan labs caused the pandemic, but there is circumstantial evidence to suggest such is the case." State Department officials then further noted that Chinese authorities sealed off the Wuhan lab in Januar y 2020, and Huang Yanling, a lab employee rumored to be "patient zero," disappeared. DEBUNKING 'CONSPIR ACY THEORY' Beginning on Jan. 3, 2020, Chinese communist officials, while insisting on the natural origin of the coronavirus, forbade the release of any information related to the pandemic without govern- ment approval. Nonetheless, America's top federal public health officials, National Institutes of Health Director Francis Collins and Dr. An- thony Fauci, seemed morally certain that COVID-19 had a natural origin and NIH-fund- ed scientists fell into line. For example: On March 7, 2020, The Lancet, a prestigious British medical journal, published a remarkable letter pro- claiming "solidarity" with Chinese colleagues combat- ing COVID-19 and decr ying "conspiracy theories" that hinder international cooper- ation. The letter was signed by 26 scientists, including Peter Daszak, president of EcoHealth Alliance, the firm that had worked closely with the Wuhan Institute of Virology and had received $8 million in American taxpayer funding. On March 17, 2020, Nature Medicine, a professional journal, published an article concluding that the nov- el coronavirus was not a "laborator y construct." That article was signed by six scientists, including Dr. Kris- tian Andersen of the Scripps Research Institute, another recipient of substantial NIH funding. On March 26, 2020, NIH chief Collins followed up with a blog post, highlighting the March 17 Nature Medicine article, and condemning "outrageous" claims that the novel coronavirus was engineered in a lab. Following this aggressive public relations offensive, in an April 2020 email, Collins told Fauci that they still had to find some way to "put down this ver y destructive conspiracy." Collins warned that the emergence of the "lab leak" theor y could damage "science and inter- national harmony." Fauci responded that the lab leak theor y was a "shiny object" that would fade with time. 'GAIN OF FUNCTION' CONTROVERSY Viral "gain of function" research—that is, research that genetically engineers a virus to make it more lethal and more transmissible—is a critical piece of the puzzle. In sworn testimony before the Senate last year, Fauci steadfastly denied that NIH funded "gain of function" research in China. In recent sworn testimony before the House of Representatives, Dr. Lawrence Tabak also denied that NIH had funded such research. Yet, the April 2020 State Department memo makes clear: Dr. Shi Zheng Li—the so-called Bat Woman of China—"conducted genetic engineering of bat virus to make it easily transmissible to humans." Shi functioned as a "subcontractor" of EcoHealth Alliance, the firm that had gotten substantial grant funding from NIH and also collaborated with Dr. Ralph Baric of the University of North Carolina, as well as other scientists, on research (reviewed by the NIH) into the potential of bat coronavi- ruses to infect humans. KEY QUESTIONS From a practical perspective, lawmakers drilling down on the pandemic's origins need to enlist the assistance of scientists who specialize in evolutionar y virology in assessing the evidence. They must also call prominent independent virologists, especially those who have been publicly engaged on the issue, to provide congressio- nal testimony. Furthermore, lawmakers must also determine what role, if any, that federal officials may have played in funding research that might have contributed to the pandemic. Among the key questions: • If the novel coronavirus emerged in nature, is there any hard evidence of any an- imal having SARS -CoV-2 be- fore the first cases of human infection? • With the shutdown of any information coming out of Communist China without government approval on Jan. 3, 2020, how could feder- al health officials—particu- larly Collins and Fauci—be morally certain that the pan- demic was not the product of a lab leak? Had they come into possession of any scien- tifically verifiable evidence since January 2020 to sup- port such a conclusion? • What new evidence did Scripps' Andersen and Rob- ert Garry of Tulane Medi- cal School, both of whom ex- pressed strong skepticism about the natural origins of the coronavirus to NIH of- ficials, have in their posses- sion that caused them to change their initial assess- ment? • Did either Collins or Fauci, or anyone on their staffs, suggest, encourage, provide comments to, or re- view the multiple authors' correspondence in The Lan- cet or the article in Nature Medicine? • How many of the 26 au- thors of The Lancet corre- spondence, or the six au- thors of the Nature Medi- cine article, had then been recipients of NIH grant funding? • Given NIH's poor over- sight, plus the failure of Eco- Health Alliance to provide NIH with timely informa- tion on the Wuhan experi- ments, as Rep. Debbie Le- sko, R-Ariz., has observed, how could federal officials know for sure that there was no taxpayer funding of "gain of function" research? • When NIH officials were debunking the lab leak theory as a "conspiracy the- ory" in April 2020, were they also aware that State Depart- ment personnel had arrived at a very different conclusion at roughly the same time? Given the gravity of the sub- ject, was there sufficient in- teragency communication? Was the White House made aware of these divergent as- sessments among career civil servants? As for Fauci's "shiny object," it just got brighter. If top NIH officials and their media allies had hoped to dis- miss the laborator y origins of the novel coronavirus as a silly "conspiracy theor y," they clearly failed. Bolstered by new intel- ligence, analysts at the Department of Energy and at the FBI have reinforced the initial assessment of State Department personnel made three years ago: The "circum- stantial evidence" indicated that the pandemic emerged from a lab. Congress must keep digging. Robert Mof fit specializes in health care and entitlement programs, especially Medi- care. Tuesday, March 14, 2023 B2 South Gibson Star-Times We've been giving it to South Gibson and the surrounding counties for a long time, why not share what news you have with others? NEWS! South Gibson Cindy Petty, advertising | startimesads@gmail.com James Rae, Jr. Editor | editor@sgstartimes.com The Dash XD upgrades include more deck sizes, a more bolstered seat, more horsepower with a Kawasaki ® engine, and larger BigBite™ rear tires. At this price point, the Dash XD's beefy construction clearly separates it from other brands. • Up to ¾-Acre • 34", 42" & 48" Decks • 15hp & 18hp Kawasaki® Engine • 2yr / 200hr Residential Warranty Mon-Fri 7AM - 6PM Saturday 7AM - 5PM Sunday 10AM - 4PM Hwy. 41 N. at Lyles Station Rd Princeton • 812-385-2641 Memmer's emmer's Hardware & Outdoor Power Do It Best Advantage: No fees for using credit card! OPINION submit Letters to the editor: Letters must be signed and received by noon on Thursday. Email: editor@sgstartimes.com Race for the Cure By Star Parker Biden supports Republicans in blocking D.C. crime bill President Joe Biden an- nounced he will not veto a resolution passed by the Republican-controlled House which overturns a new District of Columbia crime re- form law, as- suming the resolution passes in the Senate. The district is under federal jurisdiction, so Congress can overturn D.C. legisla- tion. But this is the first time in 30 years that it has happened. Now a shell-shocked chair of the left-wing D.C. city council says he's pulling the bill, which reduces sentencing on many felonies, including carjackings and burglaries, as it heads for defeat in a Senate vote still scheduled to occur. You are justified in rubbing your eyes in disbelief that Biden has sided with Repub- licans. Even more so that this goes against the grain of Democrats who support home rule, freeing D.C. from federal jurisdiction. The liberal online journal Slate ran a headline saying the president "stabbed D.C.in the back." But Biden remains in touch with political reality. NBC news reported in early Januar y that the new year started off with a notable spike in crime in D.C. compared to the same period the year before. Thefts from cars were reported up 30%, car thefts up 113%, robberies up 57% and overall property crime up 42%. Per The Washington Post, police records show that in the first two months of 2023, D.C. homicides were up 34% compared to the same period in 2022. Just a few weeks ago, Demo- cratic Rep. Angie Craig was attacked inside an elevator in the D.C. building where she resides. She succeeded in escaping the assailant, who physically assaulted her, by throwing her hot morning coffee on him. Per Craig, "I got attacked by someone who the District of Columbia has not prose- cuted fully over the course of almost a decade, over the course of 12 assaults before mine that morning." Biden's fine-tuned political nose detects the fragrance of an upcoming election year, and he has plenty to worr y about. He enjoyed a 57% percent approval rating per Gallup in the early months of his presidency. But by the end of 2021, he was down to 42% and has hov- ered around there since. Particularly bad news for the president is that, per Gal- lup, his latest approval rating on dealing with economy is 34%. Per polling in Februar y from Pew Research, the issue of most concern to Americans is the economy, with 75% saying "strengthening the economy" should be the number one priority of the president and congress. And per Gallup, only 25% of those polled are satisfied with the state of the economy. Crime is also a priority issue and here also Americans are not pleased. Only 27% say they are satisfied with "the nation's policies to reduce or control crime." Surely, Biden also had an eye on the mayoral election in Chicago. There incumbent mayor Lori Lightfoot was decisively ousted by voters, getting just 17% of the vote in a field of nine candidates. This was the first time in 40 years that an incumbent mayor in Chicago failed in a reelection bid. And a hot issue in Chicago is the dismal state of affairs regarding crime. Per the Wall Street Journal, "There were more than 800 murders in Chicago in 2021, the most in a quarter-centur y. The homicide rate dropped 14% in 2022, but remained nearly 40% higher than in 2019." So why did Biden play ball with Republicans on the D.C. crime bill? Political instincts conquer all. Biden and his party are weak on the two issues voters give highest priority to -- the economy and crime. Our president is tr ying to sur vive. His refusal to veto the Republican-led resolution on the D.C. crime bill was his way of saying that things are looking good for Republicans in 2024. Star Parker is president of the Center for Urban Renewal and Education and host of the weekly television show "Cure America with Star Parker."

