The South Gibson Star-Times serves the towns of Haubstadt, Owensville and Fort Branch.
Issue link: https://www.ifoldsflip.com/i/1172716
B-11 Tuesday, October 1, 2019 South Gibson Star-Times Lucid Moments By Bart Stinson Generation Z role models Heritage Viewpoint By Stephen Moore Elizabeth Warren's Social Security scam Minority View By Walter E. Williams Youth and ignorance Elizabeth Warren has a soak-the- rich plan for every problem in Ameri- ca. To make the math of any of these fiscal concoctions work, she's going to have find a lot more rich people to tax. The latest scheme is to increase Social Security monthly benefits for current and future retirees by about $200 a month from the current aver- age of about $1,400 a month and tax- ing the top 1 percent. The Social Security trust fund is ex- pected to be out of money in about 16 years, so this give-away would obvi- ously accelerate the retirement pro- gram's financial demise. To make up for the shortfall, Ms. Warren would impose a new 14.8 per- cent payroll tax on Americans who earn more than $250,000 and extend the payroll tax to income on invest- ments, such as dividend checks and capital gains from stocks and assets when they are sold. This taxing plan — on top of the annual wealth tax she supports and her intention to cancel the Trump income tax rate cuts for those earning more than $250,000 would raise the highest tax rate on earnings from the current 37 percent to at least 52 percent. Income tax rates haven't been this high in almost 40 years. When rates were above 50 percent in the 1970s, rich people engaged in so much tax avoidance that the share of taxes paid by the top 1 percent was actually much lower than the share of taxes the rich pay today. This would erase almost all of the pro-growth gains of the Trump tax cuts. The raising of the capital gains tax from 23.8 percent today to about 40 percent (including the wealth tax) would be the largest tax increase on investment and saving in American history. It would double the rate from where it stood as recently as 2000, when Bill Clinton was president and lowered the tax to 20 percent. Memo to progressive Democrats: The cut in the capital gains tax under Mr. Clin- ton led to the biggest increase in cap- ital gains revenues in American his- tory and helped balance the budget. Suffice it to say that under this scheme, Social Security will go broke before a single Gen Xer or millennial ever sees a dime. But even more preposterous is the idea that tax rates levied on small business owners — most people in the top 1 percent own, operate or in- vest in small, start-up firms — can be raised to way above the rates imposed by other rival nations without wreck- ing American competitiveness. Under Mr. Trump, the U.S. econo- my is now growing faster than almost any other industrial nation, and mon- ey is pouring into the United States as reflected by the strong dollar. Our tax rates under Ms. Warren (and Bernie Sanders and most of the rest of crew of Democratic presidential wannabes) would soar overnight from near the lowest to near the highest in the world. This makes as much sense as high-flying Texas with no income tax deciding to adopt the sky-high tax rates of Illinois, New York and New Jersey where people and jobs are leav- ing by the hundreds of thousands each year. This plan would destroy so many millions of jobs in America that Social Security payments for many workers would likely fall, rather than rise, be- cause they will be unemployed longer and will have worked fewer hours. Perhaps the worst feature of the Warren plan is that it overtly turns So- cial Security into what is was never in- tended to be when FDR signed the pro- gram into law: an income redistribu- tion welfare program. Social Security from when it was es- tablished in the 1930s as a national so- cial insurance system has always been based on the idea that workers pay into the system to cover their monthly So- cial Security checks later in life when they retire. The plan has a progres- sive benefit structure, meaning that a low-income worker gets more back per dollar paid in than a high-income worker (although the system is a bad deal for all workers compared to put- ting the money into a personal retire- ment account). But even a New Dealer like FDR never meant it to be an explicit welfare program with the rich paying largely the freight for the costs of everyone else. Ms. Warren wants to even pro- vide benefits to people who rarely if Social Security Matters By Russell Gloor Will my husband's income affect my benefits? Dear Rusty: Since it looks like a good option for me to retire at 62 and my hus- band (who is younger than me) to retire at 67, will the income he makes after I retire affect my benefit amount by way of income taxes if we continue to file jointly? Also, how would receiving an inheritance affect my benefit amount if I file at 62? Signed—Wor- ried Spouse. Dear Worried: Your husband's income won't directly affect your monthly Social Se- curity benefit payments at all, but it may af- fect the tax liability on your Social Security benefits. Only earnings from you working will affect your monthly Social Security ben- efits, but whether the benefits you receive become taxable income to the IRS depends upon the level of your "combined income" for your IRS filing status. "Combined income" is your Adjusted Gross Income (AGI) as report- ed to the IRS, plus any non-taxable interest you may have, plus 50 percent of your yearly Social Security benefits. This is also known as your "mod- ified adjusted gross income" or "MAGI." If you file your income taxes as "married – filing jointly," and your combined income for both you and your husband is more than $ 32,000, then up to 50 per- cent of your Social Securi- ty benefits will become tax- able income. If your MAGI is over $44,000 then up to 85 percent of your Social Securi- ty benefits will become taxable. What that means in tax dollars depends upon your nor- mal income tax rate as defined by the IRS. For information, the MAGI clip levels are lower when filing as an individual - if filing "single" MAGI over $25,000 means that up to 50 percent of Social Securi- ty benefits are taxable and MA- GI over $ 34,000 means that up to 85 percent of Social Security benefits are taxable. But the ad- vantages of filing jointly versus filing single usually more than offset the difference (though you may want to consult a tax advisor to confirm that). As to your last question, an inheritance won't affect your monthly Social Security benefit (only your earnings from working will affect your So- cial Security benefit), but if that inheritance is taxable by the IRS, then the portion of your Social Security benefits which are taxable could be affected, as described above. Pursuit of the Cure By Star Parker Secretary Carson's innovation in homeless policy Ben Carson, the neurosur- geon-turned-secretary of Housing and Urban Development, has written many books. One of them is called "You Have a Brain." The book is not about neurosurgery. The title is a quote from his single moth- er, who raised him and his brother and led them out of lives of poverty to successful careers. When one of the lads would confront a problem and turn to their mother, she would say, "You have a brain — use it." This simple bit of wisdom should be em- ployed with greater frequency in public policy debate and discussion in our coun- try. Carson is once again under attack by liberals, who are distorting perfectly le- gitimate observations he made regard- ing concerns of admittance of transgender women into federally funded women's homeless shelters. The press headlines read that Carson made "hateful" remarks demeaning trans- gender individuals. Predictably, with no seri- ous investigation into what Carson actually said or meant, a host of Democrats are calling for his resignation. Carson, in discussions with staff, said he was conveying concerns he heard from women at homeless shelters regard- ing "big, hairy men" who "would come in and have to be accepted into the women's shelter even though it made the women in the facility very uncomfortable." Carson went on to clarify and said: "Our society is in danger when we pick one is- sue (such as gender identity) and say it does not matter how it impacts others because this one issue should override ev- ery other common-sense con- sideration. I think we have to look out for everyone, and we need to use our intellectual capabilities to find com- mon good rather than attempting to al- I've noticed an emerging theme in uni- versity advertising for prospective students, whether on hometown highway billboards or in airport displays in distant cities. The ads show images of young people who appear to be in their late teens or early 20s, and the text promises that higher education will turn them into role models. I would hope some of those clever, dili- gent youngsters will, in due time, become role models for their contemporaries, and for those who come behind them. The most ex- traordinary among them may even serve as inspiration for their elders. But the idea that a university can mass produce role models on demand is silly. It puts the cart before the horse. You really ought to be an achiever or an overcomer be- fore you inspire anybody. And so university advertising ought to emphasize the worth of intellectual growth and competence, the no- bility of a quest for truth and wisdom, rath- er than speculating that acclaim will follow on its heels. You would hope for your youngster to acquire a ro- bust spirit of inquiry at col- lege, and a stubborn reliance on evidence. You want them to grow into courage of their convictions, not a timid con- formity to fashionable opin- ions. If they are eventually ad- mired for these traits or for the achievements that result, if others come to admire them as role mod- els, that's nice. But prestige is no substitute for virtue or accomplishment, and sometimes it's a hollow counterfeit. Approval-hungry adolescents, eager to be accepted into the tribe of smart ones, are es- pecially susceptible to apostasy from their Christian faith within weeks of arrival on campus. I assume that the "role model" advertis- ing is based on research that prospective students find it per- suasive. Opinion surveys and focus groups must indicate that high school seniors are motivat- ed primarily by the desire to be role models rather than to pene- trate the mysteries of science or to master the discipline of crit- ical thinking. College, for such students, will be about self. That would be consistent with the messaging of the current Democratic presidential candidates, and with the man- ner in which the mainstream Liberal media have framed students' economic issues. Excessive student debt is portrayed as sneaky fine print for the college graduate who feels betrayed to discover that borrowed Camille Paglia is a professor of human- ities and media studies at the University of the Arts in Philadelphia, where she has been a faculty member since 1984. Paglia describes herself as transgender, but un- like so many other transgender people, she is pro-capitalism and hostile to those who'd restrict free speech. She's a libertar- ian. As to modern ideas that include "gen- der-inclusive pronouns" such as zie, sie and zim, Paglia says it is lunacy. In a 2017 inter- view, Paglia was especially irritated by the thought police running college campuses to- day. In defending University of Toronto pro- fessor Jordan Peterson, who has become a pariah for his refusal to cave in to nonsensi- cal gender-inclusive pronouns, Paglia said that the English language was created by great artists such as Chaucer and Shake- speare, Wordsworth and Joyce. She added: "How dare you, you sniveling little maniac, tell us how we're gonna use pronouns! Go take a hike." On feminism, Paglia criticiz- es what she calls the "antisex and repressively doctrinaire side of feminism." She calls it "victim feminism" and com- plains that "everything we'd won in the 1990s has been to- tally swept away. Now we have this endless privileging of vic- timhood, with a pathological vulnerability seen as the default human mode." Everyone must yield to it "in the workplace, in universities, in the demand for safe spaces." Paglia adds, "What I am saying throughout my work is that girls who are indoctrinated to see men not as equals but as oppressors and rapists are condemned to remain in a permanently juvenile condition for life." Paglia's bold statements got her in a bit of hot water last April. University of the Arts students demanded that she be fired over public com- ments she'd made that were not wholly sympathetic to the #MeToo movement, as well as for an interview with the Weekly Standard that they called "transphobic." That latter denunciation is particularly slapstick, since Paglia describes herself as "transgender," writes Tunku Varadarajan, Hoover Institution's institution- al editor, in his Aug. 30 Wall Street Journal article "A Feminist Capitalist Professor Un- der Fire." The students' demand that Paglia be fired fell on deaf ears. Fortunately, there are a Continued on page 12 Continued on page 12 Continued on page 12 Continued on page 12

