South Gibson Star-Times

August 13, 2019

The South Gibson Star-Times serves the towns of Haubstadt, Owensville and Fort Branch.

Issue link: https://www.ifoldsflip.com/i/1154267

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 15 of 16

B-7 Tuesday, August 13, 2019 South Gibson Star-Times Heritage Viewpoint By Stephen Moore Why the fed is right to inject economy with more dollars Minority View By Walter E. Williams Was Trump right about Baltimore? Pursuit of the Cure By Star Parker After the shootings: Look to culture, not politics Suddenly, nearly everyone wants the Fed- eral Reserve Board to cut interest rates. I've been arguing for this for nine months, so it's nice to see the economic intelligentsia is fi- nally persuaded. The Fed has become a re- straint on growth since last August thanks to ill-advised interest rate increases (and prom- ises to raise rates more in 2019), which slow- ly squeezed out of the economy dollar liquid- ity and tanked the stock market. Fed Chairman Jerome Powell is finally sig- naling a rate cut by 0.25 of a percentage point next week. This almost certainly will be ac- companied by a reduction in the interest rate the Fed pays banks on reserves. That poli- cy has reduced bank lending and shrunk the money pool as well. The stock market has reacted bullishly in anticipation of this de- cision to inject the economy with more dol- lars. The Fed's primary job should be price stability with minimal inflation, but for ma- ny months now, inflation has fallen below its standard target. What is bewildering is that so much of the analysis for why the Fed should cut rates is upside-down. The New York Times editorial board and others argue that a slowing econ- omy demands easier money. But that's out- moded Keynesian illogic based on the belief that money causes growth. It doesn't. In the 1970s, the Fed tried to juice growth with infla- tionary money injections; we got less growth and more inflation. But excessively tight mon- ey can choke growth, too. The reality of the Trump economy is a lot different than the easy-money crowd thinks. Yes, it's true that the trade war and global economic sluggishness has slowed domes- tic growth here at home. The U.S. growth rate surged to more than 3.5 percent last summer with no signs of inflation to be found. Now, we are at closer to 2 per- cent to 2.5 percent growth, and some of that is due to exces- sively tight money. There are all sorts of market signals of tight money. Com- modity prices are still 5 per- cent to 10 percent below where they were this time last year. The consumer price levels have been close to 1.5 percent — which is below the Fed's target. I don't want inflation, but the bigger threat right now in some markets is deflation. There are many other warnings of tight money. Nominal GDP has contracted from last year. And consider the change in mar- ket indicators today versus last August, be- fore the two rate hikes happened. Last year, the interest rate on the 10 -year Treasury was 3.1 percent. Now, it is closer to 2 percent. This is a sign of declining inflation expectations. Even more amazing is that the five-year Trea- sury Inflation Protection Securities spread, which is one of the best forward-looking mea- sures of inflation, has fallen from 2 percent to 1.6 percent over the last year. This means the market is betting on inflation of well be- low where the Fed wants it. Time for dollar liquidity. Trump is battling a culture of limits to growth at the Fed. The president is correct- ly shooting for 3 percent to 4 percent nonin- flationary growth in the economy (as was laid out in the economic plan we put together back in the 2016 campaign), but most economists at the Fed and in ac- ademia believe this is an impos- sible dream. They think 3.5 per- cent real growth — stoked by tax cuts, deregulation and do- mestic energy production — will only accelerate inflation- ary impulses. Wages under this model have to be kept un- der wraps to avoid wage-push inflation. No. Policy changes that promote the pro- duction of goods and services don't cause inflation. If anything, more output leads to lower prices. That happened in the Reagan years, when the economy boomed and infla- tion fell from 12 percent to 3 percent. Ronald Reagan proved high growth and stable prices can peacefully coexist. This happened in the Clinton years as well, when federal spending was cut dramatically. Of course, the Fed should always keep a watchful eye on inflation, and if it rears its ug- ly head, the rate cuts and other liquidity mea- sures should cease. But the limits to growth skeptics are wrong. This Trump economy has the capacity to grow north of 3 percent for years to come. Sorry, Elizabeth Warren, there is no recession or financial crisis around the corner unless the Fed mistakes like last year steer us over that cliff. Stephen Moore is the Distinguished Visiting Fellow for Project for Economic Growth at The Heritage Foundation. Here's what President Donald Trump tweeted about Baltimore's congressman and his city: "Rep. Elijah Cummings has been a bru- tal bully, shouting and screaming at the great men and women of Border Patrol about conditions at the South- ern Border, when actually his Balti- more district is far worse and more dangerous. His district is consid- ered the worst in the USA." "As proven last week during a congressional tour, the border is clean, efficient and well run, just very crowded," Trump added. Cum- ming's "district is a disgusting, rat and rodent infested mess. If he spent more time in Baltimore, may- be he could help clean up this very dangerous & filthy place." President Donald Trump's claims suggesting that Rep. Elijah Cum- mings' Baltimore-area district is "considered the worst run and most dangerous" has been called racist. But whether Trump's claims have any merit is an empirical matter set- tled by appealing to facts. Let's look at a few. In 2018, Baltimore was rated one of the "Rattiest Cities" in the na- tion by pest control company Or- kin. According to Patch Media, al- though there has been progress in the last few years, Baltimore ranks ninth in rat infestation, down from its sixth position two years ago on Orkin's list. What about safety? In 2017, St. Louis had the nation's highest murder rate, at 66.1 homicides per 100,000 residents. Baltimore came in second, with 55.8 murders per 100,000 people. The unpleasant fact is that predominantly black and Democratic-run cities have the worst records of public safety. The Trace, an independent nonprofit news organization, using 2017 data from the FBI's Uniform Crime Re- porting program, listed the 20 ma- jor U.S. cities with the highest homi- cide rates. A fter St. Louis and Bal- timore, Detroit was third, with 39.8 murders per 100,000 people. Other cities with high murder rates includ- ed New Orleans; Kansas City, Mis- souri; Cleveland; Memphis, Tennes- see; and Newark, New Jersey. With 24.1 murders per 100,000 residents, Chicago ranked ninth in the nation, followed by Cincinnati and Philadel- phia. Washington, D.C., was 17th. What about education in Balti- more? In 2016, in 13 of Baltimore's 39 high schools, not a single stu- dent scored proficient on the state's mathematics exam. In six other high schools, only 1% tested pro- ficient in math. In raw numbers, 3,804 Baltimore students took the state's math test and 14 tested pro- ficient. Citywide, only 15% of Bal- timore students passed the state's English test. Money is not the prob- lem. Of the nation's 100 largest school systems, Baltimore schools rank third in spending per pupil. Baltimore's black students re- ceive diplomas that attest that they can function at a 12th-grade level when in fact they may not be able to do so at a sixth-, seventh- or eighth-grade level. These students and their families have little rea- son to suspect that their diplomas are fraudulent. Thus, if they can- not pass a civil service exam, they will accuse the exam of being rac- ist. When they get poor grades in college and flunk out, they will attri- bute their plight to racism. The in- formation that these black students have is that they, just as white stu- dents, have a high school diploma and the only explanation they see for unequal outcomes is racism. The same story of poor education out- comes can be told about most cities with large black populations. The problems that black people confront are immune to who is the president of the U.S. Those prob- lems were not ameliorated when Barack Obama was president. Those problems are not going to be ameliorated by Trump's presi- dency, though the black unemploy- ment rate is considerably lower. The lesson for black people is that pol- iticians and government handouts are not solutions. If they were, at a public expenditure that tops $22 trillion over the past half-century, black people would not be confront- ed with today's problems. Walter E. Williams is a professor of economics at George Mason Uni- versity. The nation must now endure another gut-wrenching tragedy, with 31 having been senselessly gunned downed in Texas and Ohio over a weekend. This following a week where three were gunned down in California. My appeal is to consider these tragedies a crisis of culture and not to turn them into pol- itics, which is already happening. I'm thinking about the words of Robert F. Kennedy when he spoke to a crowd in India- napolis in April 1968, after hearing the news that Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. had been mur- dered. "In this difficult day, in this difficult time for the United States, it is perhaps well to ask what kind of a nation we are and what direction we want to move in," said Kennedy. He him- self would be assassinated shortly thereafter. Kennedy appealed to Americans to move away from "polarization" and "hatred" and toward "love and wisdom and compassion." It is a great temptation to simplify what is complex, and this tends to mean translating everything into politics, looking for some par- ticular individual to blame and looking for some simple policy answer that will alleged- ly solve the problem. But these tragedies are not simple and not partisan. They have occurred too often in our nation and have occurred under Democratic as well as Republican regimes. There is a sickness in the soul of our na- tion, and that sickness plays its way through and winds up expressed in deadly, patholog- ical acts of lonely, lost, confused individuals — disproportionately, young males. We must try to grasp the na- ture of this pathology and con- sider how it may be addressed. If we look, we can see other telling symptoms. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention re- ports that the rate of suicide in the nation is the highest since 1942. From 1999 to 2017, the sui- cide rate increased 33 percent, and in 2016, suicide was the second leading cause of death in the age range of 10 to 34. The rate of suicide among young men is more than three times higher than that of young women. On the other side of the spectrum, while young Americans are taking their own lives at an increasing rate, fewer are bringing new life into the world. The CDC reports that in 2018, for the fourth year in a row, the nation's fertility rate — the number of births per 1,000 women ag- es 15 to 44 — dropped and hit a historic low. And this has occurred coincidentally with a drop in the rate of marriage. The percent- age of American adults who are married is one-third less than where is stood half a cen- tury ago. Nicholas Eberstadt of the American Enter- prise Institute has written about the huge ex- it of prime-age males — 25 to 54 — from the workforce. In 1965, according to Eberstadt, 96.6 percent of prime-age males were work- ing. Now its 88.5 percent, meaning millions of prime-age males have aban- doned the workforce. All this has occurred as Christianity, once a pillar of American society, has been pushed to the margins. Per Gallup, in 1974, 65 per- cent of Americans expressed "a great deal" or "quite a lot" of confidence in the church or or- ganized religion. By 2019, this was down to 36 percent. Faith builds a sense of belonging to some- thing true and greater than oneself. It pro- vides meaning and an anchor in times of dif- ficulty and uncertainty. As faith and eternal truths become more marginalized, more young people, particu- larly young males, become isolated and left with a sense of meaninglessness. They lose the key framework through which one takes personal responsibility for his or her life. It produces an inclination to look for oth- ers to blame for their difficulties, for their personal struggles. Sometimes it becomes violent. There is a great price to be paid for a cul- ture of meaninglessness. This is what we should be thinking and talking about, rather than simple political an- swers and who to blame. Star Parker is an author and president of CURE, Center for Urban Renewal and Educa- tion. Contact her at www.urbancure.org.

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of South Gibson Star-Times - August 13, 2019