The South Gibson Star-Times serves the towns of Haubstadt, Owensville and Fort Branch.
Issue link: https://www.ifoldsflip.com/i/1151930
B-7 Tuesday, August 6, 2019 South Gibson Star-Times Lucid Moments By Bart Stinson Liberation Day, Guam 1944 Minority View By Walter E. Williams Conflicting Visions For the most part, people share common goals. Most of us want poor people to enjoy higher standards of living, greater traffic safety, more world peace, greater racial harmo- ny, cleaner air and water, and less crime. Despite the fact that people have common goals, we often see them grouped into contentious fac- tions, fighting tooth and nail to pro- mote polar opposite government pol- icies in the name of achieving a com- monly held goal. The conflict is cen- tered around the means to achieve goals rather than the goals them- selves. The policies that become law often have the unintended con- sequence of sabotaging the achieve- ment of the stated goal. Let's look at a policy pushed by ad- vocacy groups, politicians and poor- ly trained, perhaps dishonest, econ- omists — mandated increases in the minimum wage. Nobel Prize-winning economist Paul Krugman claimed in a 2014 interview with Business Insid- er that there is actually not much risk of significantly higher wages hurt- ing workers. He argued that low- wage workers are in non-tradable in- dustries for which production cannot be moved overseas and are in indus- tries in which labor cannot be easily replaced by technology. Krugman's vision is one that my George Mason University colleagues and I try to cor- rect. Those who argue that the price of something can be raised without people having a response to it have what economists call a zero-elastic- ity vision of the world. For them, la- bor prices can rise and employers will employ just as much labor after the price increase as before. There is no evidence anywhere that people have no response to the change in price of anything. Plus, the longer a price change remains in effect the greater the response to it. Let's examine Krugman's asser- tion that low-skilled labor cannot be easily replaced by technology. Mo- mentum Machines has built a robot that can "slice toppings like toma- toes and pickles immediately before it places the slice onto your burger, giv- ing you the freshest burger possible." The robot is "more consistent, more sanitary, and can produce about 360 hamburgers per hour." Let's Pizza is a pizza-making vending machine from Europe that can make four different kinds of pizza in about 2 1/2 minutes. Kay S. Hymowitz's article "The Mother of All Disruptions," in a spe- cial issue of City Journal, gives nu- merous examples of jobs loss through technology. According to The New York Times, 89,000 workers in gen- eral merchandise lost their jobs be- tween the beginning of November 2016 and the end of March. And it's not just the U.S. where robots are re- placing labor. Foxconn's iPhone-mak- ing facility in China has replaced 60,000 workers with robots. The economic phenomenon that people who call for higher minimum wages ignore is that when the price of anything rises, people seek substi- tutes. We see it with anything. When the price of oil rose, people sought ways to use less of it through pur- chasing more insulation for their homes and fuel-efficient cars. When the price of beef rose, people sought cheaper substitutes such as pork and chicken. The substitution ef- fect of price changes is omnipresent, but do-gooders and politicians seem to suggest that labor markets are an exception. It's bad enough when do-gooders and politicians have that vision, but it is utterly disgusting and inexcusable for a trained economist to buy into that zero-elasticity vision. It's not just Krugman. On the eve of the 2007 minimum wage increase, 650 of my fellow economists, includ- ing a couple of Nobel laureates, signed a petition that read, "We be- lieve that a modest increase in the minimum wage would improve the well-being of low-wage workers and would not have the adverse effects that critics have claimed." At the time, I wrote that I felt professional embarrassment for them; however, I felt proud that not a single member of our distinguished George Mason University economic faculty signed the petition. Convincing people of how the world really works in hopes of pro- moting more humane policies re- quires examination and falsification of false visions and premises. That's a tough job with little prospect for com- pletion. Walter E. Williams is a professor of economics at George Mason Univer- sity. Pursuit of the Cure By Star Parker Ownership, not spending, will shrink wealth gap With the next round of Democratic presiden- tial candidate debates upon us, we will surely hear more about government activism to fix ra- cial inequalities. Inequality is real and needs attention. According to the Urban Institute, average white household wealth in 2016 was $171,000 compared with average black household wealth of $17,409. Sen. Cory Booker wants government to make deposits into savings accounts for low-income children to the tune of up to $50,000 each. Sen. Kamala Harris proposes $100 billion in government subsidies for black homeown- ership. These kinds of proposals may win some black votes, but should they? Will they really make blacks and the nation better off? Government anti-poverty spending is not ex- actly a novel idea. We've been doing it since the 1960s, totaling, by some estimates, over $20 trillion since then. Has it achieved anything? Changes in the poverty rate are barely dis- cernible. And the wealth gap has just gotten bigger. Per the same Urban Institute data, the wealth gap between white and nonwhite house- holds was $45,188 in 1963, $ 92,045 in 1983 and $153,591 in 2016. If a history of spending massive sums of tax- payer funds without results is not enough to discourage this approach, how about asking where the money will come from? This fiscal year, the federal government will spend $4.5 trillion, $ 3.5 of which will be financed by tax revenue, leaving a trillion-dol- lar deficit to finance through borrowing. According to the latest "Long Term Budget Outlook" from the Congressio- nal Budget Office, "Large bud- get deficits over the next 30 years are projected to drive fed- eral debt held by the public to unprecedented levels — from 78 percent of gross domestic prod- uct (GDP) in 2019 to 144 percent by 2049." And, CBO continues, "The prospect for such high and ris- ing debt poses substantial risks for the nation ..." Sometimes it might be reasonable to take a risky plunge into debt, if the investments be- ing made with the funds raised have high po- tential return and payoff. But we're talking here about plunging the na- tion deeper into debt to spend money in ways that have always failed. Does this make sense to anyone other than politicians who might get in office as a result of buying votes? There is a way out of the darkness, but it takes principles and courage. Low-income America isn't suffering because of insufficient government dependence but be- cause of insufficient independence — owner- ship. And here we can use government policy to make things better. Per the Urban Institute, the average savings in retirement accounts in 2016 was $157,884 in white households and $25,212 in black house- holds. Black families, according to the report, "have less access to retirement savings vehi- cles and lower participation when they have access." The headline in a recent Wall Street Journal column reads, "Counter Inequality With Pri- vate Social Security Accounts." The authors, Jeff Yass and Ste- phen Moore, propose Own Amer- ica Accounts, private retirement accounts to where workers could shift 10 percent of their paycheck from Social Security. The average annual return on Social Security over the last 40 years has been about 1 percent per year, according to Yass and Moore, and stocks re- turned 6 percent per year. With Own America Accounts, an average American could have retired in 2016 with be- tween $1 and 2 million in savings over a 40 - to 45 -year working life, per Yass and Moore. Furthermore, Social Security is yet anoth- er dysfunctional government program. Social Security trustees project that in just 16 years, there will be insufficient funds to meets obli- gations. So a bad deal will get even worse when our politicians try to "save the system" by rais- ing taxes, raising the retirement age or cut- ting benefits. At minimum, make Own America Accounts available to low-income Americans, and help them build wealth through ownership rather than more government dependence. Star Parker is an author and president of CURE, Center for Urban Renewal and Educa- tion. Contact her at www.urbancure.org. The anniversary of the World War II Nor- mandy invasion was observed with solemn gravity this past June, and rightly so. But July 21 passed without mention in my town again. On that morning in 1944, an enormous American flotilla appeared on the horizon off Guam carrying soldiers and Marines who would end the islanders' 31-month ordeal of Japanese occupation. They were stubbornly loyal to Uncle Sam, these Guamanians, and some paid the ulti- mate price, usually by beheading. The most celebrated martyr was Father Dueñas, a pa- triotic Catholic priest and resistance figure whom the Japanese executed just days before the U.S. fleet materialized off the coast. The Catholic boys' high school is named for him. My daughters took hula lessons from a middle-aged local police officer whose arms were pocked with numerous vaccination scars. The Japanese had used her and other Guamanian infants for medical experiments. In the light of history, it's apparent that the U.S. government had let these people down. We made a conscious decision not to fortify Guam, despite Japan's obvious expansion- ist ambitions. As a result, the Chamorro people there endured unimaginable mistreatment at the hands of a fierce foe, and when the U.S. Na- vy returned to reclaim the island, it was at the price of physical obliteration. Most of the island's priests were interned in mainland Japan, and the laity filled the vacuum. The invaders sent Japanese priests to the island but most locals considered them spies and avoided them as much as possible. Local police were put in a terrible position between their indigenous kinsmen and the invaders. "Interrogator" became a very bad word, and some families struggled for years after the war to exonerate their elders of col- laboration with the Japanese. But some locals did collabo- rate. Every society has oppor- tunistic individuals alert to po- tential advantages of alliance with intruders. And Guam was no exception. Some took Jap- anese names, but some of the most valiant patriots also had Japanese names, so the sur- name is no indication today of the disloyalty of one's ances- tor. Navy frogmen worked in darkness to dis- mantle underwater Japanese mines and ob- structions at the edge of the reef on the in- vasion beaches. Men in one southern village carved and concealed a canoe that the Japanese had for- bidden for security reasons. When the time came, these men uncovered their boat and paddled out to the fleet where suspicious U.S. seamen pulled them aboard under gunpoint. They eventually made their way to the map table, where they were debriefed about Japanese troop dispositions and fortifica- tions, most of which were built with forced Chamorro labor. Deep in the jungle, local workers turned machetes against their guards and labor overseers as Americans came ashore at Ag- at and Asan. There is a national park at the Asan inva- sion site now. Most of the visitors are Jap- anese. Americans are strangely indifferent to the valor, the sacrifices and accomplish- ments of the Greatest Generation there. The truth is that many Americans have grown cold to the republic whose flag those lads carried. Patriotism has been purged from popular culture and from K-12 education, for the most part. If we believe that America "was never that great," as one MSNBC Democrat opined, there's nothing stirring about the unyielding patriotism of the Chamorro people during their ordeal, much less their deliv- erance by young Americans at the cost of lives lost and bodies maimed, futures forfeited. You probably have met some Chamorros if you were in the military. They volunteer at much higher rates than the rest of us. You may have met some if you lived on the West Coast. In some places there are enough of them to celebrate Liberation Day, July 21. But I think you should be celebrating Lib- eration Day whether you can find a Chamor- ro in your hometown or not. It puts meat on the skeleton of theoretical patriotism. It's something to reflect on, something for your grandchildren to think about: loyal Americans dispossessed, brutalized and op- pressed in their own land by foreign invad- ers, then rescued and restored by other loy- al Americans. If we're not patriotic enough to fortify our border, we will eventually share Guam's 1941 fate: our children and grandchildren will be subject to the will of their invaders. But will 1944 come for us? Who will gather on our horizon to deliver us from our occu- piers? Our story is unlikely to end as well as Guam's. It's a lot easier to preserve our lib- erty than to regain it.

