The South Gibson Star-Times serves the towns of Haubstadt, Owensville and Fort Branch.
Issue link: https://www.ifoldsflip.com/i/1122403
B-11 Tuesday, May 28, 2019 South Gibson Star-Times Taking aim at the Arms Trade Treaty Minority View by Walter E. Williams Socialist promises Heritage Viewpoint by Edwin J. Feulner Presidential contenders are in a battle to out give one another. Sen- ator Elizabeth Warren proposes a whopping $50,000 per student col- lege loan forgiveness. Senator Ber- nie Sanders proposes free health care for all Americans plus illegal aliens. Most Democratic presiden- tial candidates promise free stuff that includes free college, univer- sal income, "Medicare for All" and debt forgiveness. Their socialist predecessors made promises too. "Freedom and Bread" was the slogan used by Adolf Hitler during the Nation- al Socialist German Workers' Par- ty (Nazi) campaign against presi- dent Paul von Hindenburg. Hitler even promised, "In the Third Re- ich every German girl will find a husband." Stalin promised a great socialist-Marxist society that in- cluded better food and better work- er conditions. China's Mao Zedong promised democratic constitution- alism and the dream that "farmers have land to till." These, and oth- er promises, gave Mao the broad political support he needed to win leadership of the entire country in 1949. Socialism promises a utopia that sounds good, but those promises are never realized. It most often re- sults in massive human suffering. Capitalism fails miserably when compared with a heaven or utopia promised by socialism. But any earthly system is going to come up short in such a comparison. Man- kind must make choices among al- ternative economic systems that actually exist. It turns out that for the common man capitalism, with all of its alleged shortcomings, is superior to any system yet devised to deal with his everyday needs and desires. By most any measure of human well-being, people who live in coun- tries toward the capital- istic end of the econom- ic spectrum are far bet- ter off than their fellow men who live in coun- tries toward the social- ist end. Why? Capitalism, or what some call free mar- kets, is relatively new in human history. Prior to capital- ism, the way individuals amassed great wealth was by looting, plun- dering and enslaving their fellow man. With the rise of capitalism, it became possible to amass great wealth by serving and pleasing your fellow man. Capitalists seek to discover what people want and produce and market it as efficient- ly as possible as a means to prof- it. A historical example of this pro- cess would be John D. Rockefel- ler, whose successful marketing drove kerosene prices down from 58 cents a gallon in 1865 to 7 cents in 1900. Henry Ford became rich by producing cars for the com- mon man. Both Ford's and Rocke- feller's personal benefits pale in comparison to the benefits re- ceived by the common man who had cheaper kerosene and cheaper and more convenient transporta- tion. There are literally thousands of examples of how mankind's life ha been made better by those in the pursuit of profits. Here's my question to you: Are the people who, by their actions, created un- precedented convenience, longer life expectancy and a more pleas- ant life for the ordinary person — and became wealthy in the process — deserving of all the scorn and ridicule heaped upon them by intellectuals and political hustlers today? In many intellec- tual and political circles, the pursuit of profits is seen as evil. However, this pursuit forces entre- preneurs to find ways to either please peo- ple efficiently or go bankrupt. Of course, they could mess up and avoid bankruptcy if they can get government to bail them out or give them protection against com- petition. Nonprofit organizations have an easier time of it. As a matter of fact, people tend to be the most displeased with services received from public schools, motor vehi- cle departments and other govern- ment agencies. Nonprofits can op- erate whether they please people or not. That's because they derive their compensation through taxes. I'm sure that we'd be less satisfied with supermarkets if they had the power to take our money through taxes, as opposed to being forced to find ways to get us to voluntari- ly give them our money. By the way, I'm not making an outright condemnation of social- ism. I run my household on the Marxist principle, "From each ac- cording to his ability, to each ac- cording to his needs." That system works when you can remember the names of all involved. Walter E. Williams is a professor of economics at George Mason Uni- versity. Pursuit of the Cure by Star Parker Alabama abortion law on right track When we talk about "pro-life" in our national discussion about abortion, "life" is understood to be about the unborn child in the mother's womb. But it would serve us well to expand our understanding about what "pro-life" means. We should understand that re- specting the sanctity of life is key to the values and behaviors in gen- eral that sustain and nourish all our lives today and create the nec- essary conditions for our future. A just-released report from the National Center for Health Statis- tics, a unit of the Centers for Dis- ease Control and Prevention, re- ports that the total number of births in the United States in 2018 was down 2 percent from 2017 and is the lowest number of births in the country in 32 years. It also reports that the gener- al fertility rate — the number of births per 1,000 women aged 15 - 44 — was also down 2 percent and is at a record low. The total fertility rate needs to be 2,100 births per 1,000 wom- en to keep our overall population at steady state — not shrinking. It now stands at 1,728 per 1,000 women. If the alternative to "pro-life" is so-called "pro-choice," the mind- set of legal abortion on demand, the latter is capturing, and de- stroying, American society. We are choosing to extinguish our- selves. It turns out that "reproductive freedom," the banner under which "pro-choice" operates, translates into the freedom to not reproduce. University of Southern Califor- nia demographer Dowell Myers calls the declining birthrates we are witnessing a "barometer of de- spair." Birthrates de- cline, according to Myers, when people are not op- timistic about the future. How about the general collapse of the marriage insti- tution? In 1960, 72 per- cent of Americans 18 and above were married. By 2016, this was down to 50 percent. At a conference at the Vatican in 2014, Rabbi Jonathan Sacks, for- mer chief rabbi of the United King- dom, called marriage "the single most humanizing institution in his- tory." He said that life begins "when male and female meet and em- brace." "Morality," he continued, "is the love between husband and wife, parent and child, extended out- ward to the world." A society in which sanctity of life is respected is a society that appreciates that we are all part of something larger than ourselves. When we lose this awe, this appre- ciation for the sacred, we discon- nect from one another and disap- pear into our separate selves. Love, marriage, children and our future begin to recede. It's a spiritual tragedy with pro- found and destructive practical im- plications for society. The Census Bureau projects that in 2035, for the first time, the number of Americans over the age of 65 will exceed the number of Americans under 18. As society ages, the number of retirees per each working American increases — what is called the dependen- cy ratio. We are already see- ing the implications with huge deficits in our social securi- ty and Medicare pro- grams, where pay- roll taxes finance re- tirement and health care costs of the elderly. A healthy pushback is starting to occur at the nation's grassroots. States are getting aggressive to stop the destructive abortion cul- ture. Most recently, Alabama and Georgia have enacted laws making abortion that is legal under federal law illegal in the state. This puts state law on a collision course with federal law. Whether this will wind up at the Supreme Court with a revisiting of the Roe v. Wade decision remains to be seen. We should be praying it will hap- pen. The current abortion culture that has been defining America since the Roe v. Wade decision in 1973 is part and symptomatic of an America whose future is in danger. We must fight for restoration of a pro-life culture in our country that respects the sanctity of life and will restore the American family, children and our future. Star Parker is an author and president of CURE, Center for Ur- ban Renewal and Education. Con- tact her at www.urbancure.org. Some of the most notable policy victories take time — and they sel- dom generate banner headlines. Take the Arms Trade Treaty. There's an excellent chance that you're saying, "The what? " There was a relatively minor ripple in the news cycle when President Trump announced he was withdrawing the United States from it. But believe me, it matters. And it was the right move. The Arms Trade Treaty (AT T) probably sounded harmless enough to most people when the United Nations first voted on it about a decade ago. Its goal: "es- tablishing common international standards for the import, export and transfer of conventional arms." What could go wrong? Plenty. And The Heritage Foun- dation's Ted Bromund, who has monitored the AT T from the start, wasted no time in sounding the alarm bells. "Although putatively intended as [a] measure that would reduce conflicts and limit the ability of ter- rorists and organized crime to ob- tain weapons, the treaty contem- plated by the resolution would in reality be a license to almost all states, no matter how irresponsi- ble, to buy and sell arms," he wrote in a 2009 report. "The projected treaty would en- danger U.S. arms export control policy, clash with the Constitution, offer a dangerous justification for dictatorial rule, and make it ille- gal under international law for the U.S. to support freedom fighters abroad." Unfortunately, it often takes more than one report — no mat- ter how well-reasoned — to stop a bad idea in its tracks. So Mr. Bro- mund kept at it. He attended the 2012, 2013, 2015 and 2018 Arms Trade Treaty con- ferences. He even addressed the United Nations in 2012 and 2013. Along the way, he published more than 200 related reports, op-eds, scholarly articles, lectures and blog posts on the Arms Trade Treaty. He also gave countless me- dia interviews. On the other side, in full support of the treaty, was a large coalition of gun-control proponents, and left-wing, non-governmental orga- nizations. They campaigned hard, and found a sympathetic ear in the Obama White House. In 2013, Sec- retary of State John Kerry signed the Arms Trade Treaty. The Senate, however, never rati- fied the treaty. And now, with Pres- ident Trump's announcement, it's off the table. So what's wrong with the Arms Trade Treaty? For one thing, as the White House pointed out, it pro- vides "a platform for those who would seek to constrain our abil- ity to sell arms to our allies and partners." That's a key goal of the Arms Trade Treaty's support- ers: tying the hands of the Unit- ed States (which, unlike many oth- er signatories to treaties, actually honors its commitments). Another problem: The Arms Trade Treaty has "a track record of being used by groups to try and overturn sovereign national decisions on arms exports," the White House says. No one who cares about national sovereignty should consent to such an agree- ment. Just ask the British, who have been sued repeatedly by the activists in the name of the treaty. Then there's the matter of the Second Amendment. Oh, the trea- ty's supporters assure us that the AT T won't affect our right to own guns. But as Mr. Bromund points out, they also refuse to make that clear in the treaty text. So sure, the treaty (at least as now written) is no gun grab. But gun-control ac- tivists could still use it to advance their goals. And let's not forget a major flaw in the Arms Trade Treaty, at least if we're to take it seriously. China and Russia, both of which are ma- jor arms exporters, aren't party of the treaty. So President Trump was right to say he was un-signing the Arms Trade Treaty. But we shouldn't stop there. The treaty still has 102 state parties around the world, so Lucid Moments By Bart Stinson War of 1812 The War of 1812 bicentennials passed with little fanfare in our corner of the Midwest, although it was a partly a contest for this re- gion. The U.S. declared war that June, and it raged on until Feb- ruary 1815. It was no lark, and brought our fledgling republic to the verge of extinction. American commanders antic- ipated danger at Fort Dearborn (Chicago), and ordered the evac- uation of 148 soldiers, women and children that first August. But 500 British-allied Potawatomi am- bushed them along the trail. They killed 86, including two women and 12 children. A fter felling one especially valiant de- fender, they cut out his heart and ate it, to absorb his courage. The Potawatomi marched their cap- tives back to Fort Dearborn, which they burned to the ground on the following day. Some of the ambushed Ameri- cans survived the battle, but not their captivity. Others were even- tually ransomed. Whether it's fair to call the battle a massacre or not, the Potawatomi attack helped gal- vanize white public opinion against pluralistic coexistence with Native American societies. In the long run, winning the Bat- tle of Fort Dearborn is possibly the worst thing that could have hap- pened to the Potawatomi. They were eventually dispossessed and expelled from their ancestral lands by white settlers who were unwilling to chance massacre of their loved ones every time a char- ismatic messiah figure like Tecum- seh or Tenskwatawa came along to appeal to Native American re- sentment. In the meantime, British com- manders induced some hasty fron- tier American surrenders else- where by playing "good cop, bad cop" regarding their Native Ameri- can allies' tendency toward massa- cre of their captives. But U.S. forc- es under William Henry Harrison deprived the British terror strat- egy of some of its bite when they hunted Tecumseh down in Canada and killed him at the Battle of the Thames in October 1813. Native Americans weren't the only ones burning U.S. facilities to the ground during the War of 1812, of course. British command- er Robert Ross set the torch to Washington, including the White House, in August 1814. The Brit- ish drove James Madison and his military commanders out of Wash- ington, into what is now Montgom- ery County, Maryland. The invaders occupied Wash- ington before a king-sized storm damaged their fleet, extinguished their fires, and spun off a tornado that pitched two of their cannon in- to the air and tumbled them down Constitution Avenue. The British were haughty and stubborn peo- ple but they could take a hint, and abandoned our capitol 26 hours af- ter their arrival. Baltimore put up a much tough- er defense than Washington. Mili- tia commander Samuel Smith, 62, assembled a force of 13,000 patri- ots and positioned them in a line of strong fortifications. When Ross attacked, they killed him, along with 300 of his fellow invaders. The British then went to plan B: they called their fleet up close to shore to bombard Fort McHenry, which was all that kept the invad- ers out of Baltimore harbor. The bombardment went on all day, and then all night. The fabled British fleet pounded Baltimore like an anvil: rockets, bombs, "a firelit clang," as historian Bruce Catton wrote, "of broken metal against masonry." And yet, when morning dawned, despite heavy smoke, Francis Scott Key could see that our flag was still there. The valor in Baltimore was bal- anced by a nauseating stench of Federalist treason to the north, where the Massachusetts legisla- ture had called a wartime conven- tion of New England states to un- dermine Madison. Vermont and New Hampshire rejected the call, but Rhode Island and Connecticut, to their shame, accepted. The Federalists deliberated in secret, passed long-winded resolu- tions and proposed a series of Con- stitutional amendments, but Amer- ican public opinion had turned against them. It was inexcusable that the Federalists had leveraged the wartime crisis as a political op- portunity, and the American peo- ple were finished with them. When Continued on page 12 Continued on page 12

