The South Gibson Star-Times serves the towns of Haubstadt, Owensville and Fort Branch.
Issue link: https://www.ifoldsflip.com/i/1051247
B-8 Tuesday, November 13, 2018 South Gibson Star-Times Minority View by Walter E. Williams Skin in the game Pursuit of the Cure by Star-Parker The battle to MAGA continues Continued on page 11 President Trump's critics have found something else to rend their garments over: His determination to end so-called "birthright citi- zenship." Why, they thunder, it's unconstitutional. And even if it could be changed, it can't be by executive order. They're wrong on both counts. That probably comes as a sur- prise to many Americans, includ- ing some who consider themselves Trump supporters. Haven't we all been told for years that if you're born here, you're automatically a U.S. citizen? It's all right there in the 14th Amendment. No matter who your parents are or what their status is, you're an American. Sim- ple as that. Or is it? Consider the actual wording: "All persons born or nat- uralized in the United States and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the States wherein they re- side." Seems pretty cut and dry, but check out that crucial clause: "and subject to the jurisdiction there- of." It's easy to mumble over it, but we shouldn't. The Senate in- cluded it there for a reason when they passed the amendment in 1868: To make it clear that not ev- eryone born here is automatical- ly a citizen. Being born here is only half the equation. You also must be "sub- ject to the jurisdiction thereof." The original proposed wording of the amendment did not include that phrase. It was inserted specif- ically to make it clear that the law did not, in fact, confer citizenship on everyone born here. Sen. Jacob Howard of Michi- gan, a member of the Joint Com- mittee on Reconstruction and a strong supporter of the Citizenship Clause, noted that Congress in- tended to exclude "per- sons born in the United States who are foreign- ers, aliens, [or] who belong to the families of ambassadors or for- eign ministers accred- ited to the Government of the United States." Supreme Court cases decided in the years soon after the Amend- ment's passage confirm this view. Moreover, says constitutional scholar Edward Erler: "It is hard to conclude that the framers of the 14th Amendment intended to con- fer citizenship on the children of aliens illegally present when they explicitly denied that boon to Na- tive Americans legally present but subject to a foreign jurisdiction." Notes Hillsdale College's Mat- thew Spalding: "Few developed na- tions practice the rule of jus soli, or 'right of the soil.' More common is jus sanguinis, 'right of blood,' by which a child's citizenship deter- mined by parental citizenship, not place of birth." In short, it was wise of Congress to limit the scope of the Amend- ment. And those who misinter- pret it are wrong. President Trump should be commended for trying to bring current understanding back in line with the original in- tent of the framers. That leaves us with the ques- tion of whether he would be right to set this issue straight via an ex- ecutive order. Some people who agree with him on birthright citi- zenship, such as National Review's Andrew C. McCar- thy, believe that he shouldn't. They ar- gue that it should be done by the same body that issued the Amendment in the first place: Congress. In other words, this is a job for Con- gress, the branch of government that cre- ates our laws, not the executive, which enforces them. According to Mr. McCarthy, a president cannot "unilaterally change an understanding of the law that has been in effect for de- cades under a duly enacted feder- al law." Granted, but as constitution- al scholar Hans von Spakovsky points out, "that assumes the 'un- derstanding' is the correct one. If that understanding actually vi- olates the plain text and intent of the law, the president as the chief law-enforcement officer can, and indeed has an obligation, to di- rect the federal government to be- gin applying and enforcing it cor- rectly." To put it another way, the presi- dent here would not be attempting to make a new law, but to enforce the correct view of an existing law. Sure, his order would be imme- diately challenged. Perhaps we'd even wind up with Congress clari- fying the original intent of the law. All the more reason to do it. Fairness demands that we get this issue settled — and soon. Ed Feulner is founder of The Her- itage Foundation (heritage.org). Heritage Viewpoint by Edwin J. Feulner Being born here is only half of the Fourtheenth Amendment's equation The Weekly by Alden Heuring Brighter Side by Janice Barniak Enjoy the views By hook or by crooks In describing the GOP tax cuts, House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi said that they and bonus- es American workers were get- ting were "crumbs." They were "tax cuts for the rich." Some ar- gued that the tax cuts would re- duce revenues. Pelosi predicted, "This thing will explode the defi- cit." How about some tax facts? The argument that tax cuts reduce federal revenues can be disposed of quite easily. Accord- ing to the Congressional Bud- get Office, revenues from feder- al income taxes were $76 billion higher in the first half of this year than they were in the first half of 2017. The Treasury Department says it expects that federal reve- nues will continue to exceed last year's for the rest of 2018. De- spite record federal revenues, 2018 will see a massive deficit, perhaps topping $1 trillion. Our massive deficit is a result not of tax cuts but of profligate con- gressional spending that out- runs rising tax revenues. Grossly false statements about tax cuts' reducing revenue should be put to rest in the wake of federal reve- nue increases seen with tax cuts during the Kennedy, Reagan and Trump administrations. A very disturbing and mostly ignored issue is how absence of skin in the game negatively im- pacts the political arena. It turns out that 45 percent of American households, nearly 78 million in- dividuals, have no federal income tax obligation. That poses a se- rious political problem. Ameri- cans with no federal income tax obligation become natural con- stituencies for big-spending pol- iticians. A fter all, if one doesn't pay federal income taxes, what does he care about big spending? Also, if one doesn't pay federal taxes, why should he be happy about a tax cut? What's in it for him? In fact, those with no skin in the game might see tax cuts as a threat to their handout pro- grams. Whenever tax cuts are called for, it's not long before they are called tax cuts for the rich. Let's look at who pays what in feder- al income taxes. Using IRS data for 2015, the latest year available, the Tax Foundation reports that the top 1 percent of earners made about 21 percent of the nation's income, but their share of feder- al income taxes was 39 percent. They paid more in income tax- es than the bottom 90 percent, who paid 29.4 percent of feder- al income taxes (http://tinyurl. com/y7t4ljv8). In 2015, the top 50 percent of taxpayers paid 97.2 percent of all individual income taxes. Also, the top 1 percent had an income tax rate of 27 percent, while the bottom 50 percent had a tax rate of less than 4 percent. It turns out that 892,420 households — out of roughly 34 million total house- holds — paid 39 percent of fed- eral taxes that year. Most Amer- icans have little or no federal in- come tax obligation, so how in the world is it possible to give a tax cut to them? Another part of the Trump tax cuts was with corporate income — lowering the rate from 35 per- cent to 21 percent. That, too, has been condemned by the left as a tax cut for the rich. But corpo- rations do not pay taxes. Why? Corporations are legal fictions. Only people pay taxes. If a tax is levied on a corporation, it will have one or more of the following responses in order to remain in business. It will raise the price of its product, lower its dividends to shareholders and/or lay off workers. Thus, only flesh-and- blood people pay taxes. We can think of corporations as tax col- lectors. Politicians love our ig- norance about this. They sug- gest that corporations, not peo- ple, will be taxed. Here's how to see through this charade: Sup- pose a politician told you, as a homeowner, "I'm not going to tax you. I'm going to tax your land." I hope you wouldn't fall for that jive. Land doesn't pay taxes. Getting back to skin in the game, sometimes I wonder whether one should be allowed in the game if he doesn't have any skin in it. Walter E. Williams is a profes- sor of economics at George Mason University. America's founders demon- strated that government is art, not science. The secret is in balance. Biennial congressional elec- tions strike the right balance for the need for stability with the need for change. Midterm elections take place with the continuity of a sitting president. Whoever is in the White House will continue in this position for another two years, re- gardless of the outcome of mid- terms. By the time you read this, we'll know whether the new Congress will be red or blue. But I know now that the day after the elec- tions, Donald Trump will still be president. And I know that whatever hap- pens, Trump will stay focused, as he must, on the agenda that he campaigned on and the vision he articulated in his inaugural ad- dress. His commitment to those ideas and principles took him across the nation to insert his persona and agenda into the campaign. As we approach the two-year mark of this presidency, facts bear out that the nation is turning around and "Make America Great Again" is more than a slogan. We are a deeply divided coun- try with a culture war raging. The battle for steering the country's direction will continue. This elec- tion just determines the army that the general in the White House will have to support him in the fight. Personally, I spent the last month in eight different states, making the case for what is at stake. I spent Election Day in my district, walking precincts and making phone calls to help my candidate of choice in a race for an open seat. Trump has made it fashionable again to be a patriot, to feel proud to be an American be- cause our nation is in- deed unique and excep- tional. The other side has distorted this message of nation- alism, claiming it disrespects our diversity and individual differenc- es. Nothing could be further from the truth. The fact that I am black Chris- tian woman does not contradict my patriotism. I am an American who needs the freedom that on- ly this nation can provide to real- ize my full potential. This is true for every American. And it is on- ly possible in a nation that is free and informed by eternal truths. The changes we see in realiz- ing the MAGA (Make America Great Again) goals are tangible and palpable. Internationally, Trump's idea that the best way to influence the world is to recapture our national greatness is working. He has shaken up the United Nations and is creating new real- ities in Asia, South America and the Middle East. Despite warnings against his bold move to recognize Jerusa- lem as Israel's capital, Trump did it. And miracles are occurring throughout the Middle East. Is- rael and Persian Gulf States are forming new relationships that once were unheard of. Israel, for the first time, com- peted in an interna- tional Judo compe- tition in Abu Dhabi, won a gold medal, and the Israeli na- tional anthem was played in this Arab country. Economically, the economy is back on the path to growth. Black and Hispanic unemploy- ment are at all-time lows, and even high school dropouts are finding work as result of the new oppor- tunities. Constitutionally, the GOP Sen- ate has confirmed 68 conservative judges, with 125 left to go. Fiscally, every federal depart- ment getting anti-poverty mon- ey (one-fourth of the federal bud- get) is under Executive Order to cut spending and strike new effi- ciencies. We need secure borders. Ter- rorists from the Middle East could penetrate Central and South America, looking to cross our borders under the guise of being refugees. The bottom line is we must stay the course and continue to help this president get the nation's work done. We must continue the fight for freedom and personal responsibil- ity and national destiny through MAGA. Star Parker is an author and president of CURE, Center for Ur- ban Renewal and Education. Con- tact her at www.urbancure.org. It's quickly turning from sum- mer right past fall into winter, but the autumn scenery is out in full force this week. This weather is best enjoyed one of two ways: bundled up heavily enough to stay out in it for a few hours, or watch- ing it through a window. I've had the pleasure of doing the latter a couple times already by taking some scenic drives while the girls napped in the back seat, so this week I'd like to recommend a few nearby places, one for each point of the compass, that are great for driving or walking. First let's head north, where the reddening trees make a shady arch over Highway 231. This high- way, like most on my list, has been somewhat forgotten after Inter- state 69 was finished, but it's still just as lovely a drive as I remem- ber from my college days. It goes through lots of tiny towns on its windy way towards Indy and Lafay- ette, so there are plenty of places to stop for a meal or veer off the main road for a jaunt through the fields. To the east, you can make a day of driving down Interstate 64. There's plenty of pretty country and not much traffic, so you can set your cruise and take it all in (at 70 miles per hour of course). For stops, there's Santa Claus or Co- rydon, both with plenty of charm for passers-by to enjoy. Southward is of course Ind. 57, another casualty of I-69 that was recently paved and has rolling hills and fields on either side. If you take a drive south on 57 this week, I especially recommend a leisurely loop through Somer- ville. There are at least two beau- tiful bright-yellow trees in town that are about halfway through dropping their leaves for the sea- son, and they are worth the trip by themselves. Finally, to the west is Ind. 64 be- tween Princeton and Mount Carm- el. This is another road with plenty of little turn-offs that loop back to the highway, and some great stops as well, like Lyles Station just out- side Princeton. For best results, try to catch a sunset as you head toward Illinois. That's it for this week! Hope you get the chance to really look at some of the autumn trees this season, and have a great one! An app I use to buy discount goods online was compromised last week for $284.05, and I'm tell- ing you, thieving ain't what it used to be. It used to be a thief would have to come to your house, face you man to (wo)man, and decide which of your things they wanted to take. I've always been very safe in this regard because I own the worst absolute rubbish. I have horrible taste. My couch is La-Z-boy in such a violent orange color they practical- ly paid me to take it. It's the most comfortable thing I've ever sat on. I don't have a television, my crafty end tables made from vin- tage suitcases appeal to no one, and my elephant lamp looks like a prop from Raiders of the Lost Ark. All of my wall art is of the cray- on and marker variety. I occasionally forget to lock the door. But what would they take? My grandpa and I like to joke that we'll leave our houses and cars unlocked just in case some- one wants to wander in and lose something. "Maybe a criminal will drop a nice watch," one of us will say. So imagine my surprise, Satur-

