South Gibson Star-Times

September 18, 2018

The South Gibson Star-Times serves the towns of Haubstadt, Owensville and Fort Branch.

Issue link: https://www.ifoldsflip.com/i/1028717

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 21 of 24

B-9 Tuesday, September 18, 2018 South Gibson Star-Times One of the best statements of how the Framers saw the role of the federal government is found in Federalist Paper 45, written by James Madison, who is known as the "Father of the Constitution": "The powers delegated by the pro- posed Constitution to the federal government are few and defined. Those which are to remain in the State governments are numerous and indefinite. The former will be exercised principally on exter- nal objects, as war, peace, nego- tiation, and foreign commerce. ... The powers reserved to the sever- al States will extend to all the ob- jects which, in the ordinary course of affairs, concern the lives, liber- ties, and properties of the people." Today's reality is the polar oppo- site of that vision. The powers of the federal government are nu- merous and indefinite, and those of state governments are few and defined. If confirmed, Brett Kavanaugh will bring to the U.S. Supreme Court a vision closer to that of the Framers than the vision of those who believe that the Constitu- tion is a "living document." Those Americans rallying against Kava- naugh's confirmation are really against the U.S. Constitution rath- er than the man — Judge Kavana- ugh — whom I believe would take seriously his oath of office to up- hold and defend the Constitution. Was Madison misinformed or just plain ignorant about the pow- ers delegated to Congress? Before we answer, let's examine state- ments of other possibly "misin- formed" Americans. In 1796, on the floor of the House of Represen- tatives, William Giles of Virginia condemned a relief measure for fire victims, saying the purpose and the right of Congress is to at- tend to not what gener- osity and humanity re- quire but instead what their duty requires. In 1854, President Frank- lin Pierce vetoed a bill intended to help the mentally ill, writing to the Senate, "I can not find any authori- ty in the Constitution for making the Federal Government the great almoner of public charity." He added that to approve such spending would "be contrary to the letter and spirit of the Constitution and subversive of the whole theory upon which the Union of these States is founded." President Grover Cleveland out-ve- toed his predecessors by vetoing 584 acts of Congress, including many congressional spending bills during his two terms as president in the late 1800s. His often-given veto message was, "I can find no warrant for such an appropriation in the Constitution." By the way, President Cleveland was a Dem- ocrat. Were the Founding Fathers, previous congressmen and previ- ous presidents who could not find constitutional authority for today's massive federal government inter- vention just plain stupid, ignorant, callous and uncaring? Article 1 of the Constitution defines the role of Congress. Its Section 8 lists pow- ers delegated to Congress. I exam- ined our Constitution, looking to see whether an Article 5 amend- ment had been enacted authoriz- ing Congress to spend money for business bailouts, prescription drugs, education, Social Security and thousands of other spending measures in today's federal bud- get. I found no such amendment. Con- trary to what our Constitution per- mits, Congress taxes and spends for any- thing upon which it can muster a major- ity vote. But I found a con- stitutional loophole that many congress- men use as a blank check, as well as justification to control most as- pects of our lives — namely, the general welfare clause. The Con- stitution's preamble contains the phrase "promote the general Wel- fare," and Article 1, Section 8 con- tains the phrase "provide for the common Defense and general Wel- fare of the United States." What did the Framers mean by "gener- al Welfare"? In 1817, Thomas Jef- ferson wrote, "Congress had not unlimited powers to provide for the general welfare, but were re- strained to those specifically enu- merated." Madison wrote: "With respect to the words 'general wel- fare,' I have always regarded them as qualified by the detail of pow- ers connected with them. To take them in a literal and unlimited sense would be a metamorphosis of the Constitution into a character which there is a host of proofs was not contemplated by its creators." Case closed: It's our Constitu- tion that's the problem for leftist interventionists — not Brett Ka- vanaugh. Walter E. Williams is a profes- sor of economics at George Mason University. It's a natural question to ask ev- ery time the anniversary of the 9/11 attacks rolls around: Are we safer now than we were then? The short answer is yes. We are. But there's a huge caveat attached to that, as well as some much-need- ed context to consider. To understand what I mean, let me ask you: How many terrorist plots or attacks has the U.S. home- land faced since that fateful day in 2001? Most people, I'll bet, wouldn't guess more than a dozen. Maybe more, but not much more. Very few would guess the actual num- ber: 104. That's right. Not a dozen. Clos- er to 10 dozen. Sounds incredible, I know. But should we be surprised? A fter all, 87 of those plots were uncovered by law enforcement agencies be- fore they could carry out their deadly attacks. Foiled attacks aren't report- ed nearly as widely and breath- lessly as ones that succeed. Be- sides, they're competing with wall-to-wall coverage of political food fights. Good luck breaking through the clutter. Plus, many of these attacks are smaller in scope. They'll involve maybe one or two individuals plan- ning to plant, say, a dirty bomb at a courthouse or a shopping mall. Seventeen years later, we re- member Mohamed Atta, the tac- tical leader of the 9/11 plot. But how many have even heard of Ma- tin A zizi-Yarand? He's the 17-year- old North Texas student who was arrested in May before he could carry out his plan to launch a dead- ly shooting at a suburban mall in Dallas, Texas. A zizi-Yarand made the mistake of talking about his plans with an undercover FBI agent. His arrest warrant quotes him as saying, "I swear I want to achieve Allah's pleasure and kill the kuffar" (Arabic for "nonbeliever"). Also: "I've only been read- ing ISIS magazine guidelines for performing operations and mak- ing bombs." We've been conditioned by 9/11 to think of a terrorist at- tack as something that involves a large group hijacking huge planes and driving them into some very high-profile targets and killing thousands in one fell swoop. But the threat has shifted. Rather than a large cell and a huge attack that can be more eas- ily ferreted out, today's terrorists are pursuing a death-by-a-thou- sand-cuts strategy. It's become one big, lethal do-it-yourself proj- ect, outsourced to freelancers who have joined the cause. At least they're attempting to. The good news is that we're more secure today. It's gotten much harder for our enemies to suc- ceed, even when they diversify the threat, so to speak. That's why I said yes, we're saf- er. But the context is that the ter- rorists are still out there. They're still trying. We can't let the lack of another 9/11 lull us into a false sense of security. Another unwelcome but nec- essary bit of context: The threat that we face now is much more likely to be "homegrown" — someone radicalized in the United States, not shipped in from abroad, like the 9/11 attackers were. A zizi- Yarand, for example, grew up here. He was living with his par- ents in Plano, Texas, when he was arrested. The caveat I mentioned is that we can't afford to let up in our ef- forts to detect these plots and stop these terrorists in their tracks. In fact, we can and should do more. According to terrorism expert Da- vid Inserra, sensible steps include: • Improving our aviation secu- rity by looking to other countries and the private sector for lessons and greater efficiency. • Continuing to stress the im- portance of lawful intelligence pro- grams that help the U.S. stop ter- rorists before they strike. • Reforming oversight of the Department of Homeland Securi- ty so that our security officials get clear guidance from Congress that lets them spend more time keep- ing America safe. As the saying goes, "Eternal vig- ilance is the price of liberty." We're in a fight for our lives. It's time to redouble our resolve — and ensure that we continue to win. Ed Feulner is founder of The Her- itage Foundation (heritage.org). Pursuit of the Cure by Star-Parker Disciplinary policies must be local Heritage Viewpoint by Edwin J. Feulner After all these years, how safe are we? Minority View by Walter E. Williams It's our Constitution not Kavanaugh LETTERS TO THE EDITOR Signed copies of letters must be submitted by noon on Friday. SUBSCRIBE TODAY! 812-753-3553 We're not afraid to shed some South Gibson The Trump administration is con- sidering rescinding a Dear Colleague Letter, sent to public school adminis- trators nationwide in 2014, which pro- vided guidelines regarding school dis- cipline policies consistent with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act. According to Title VI, racial discrim- ination at institutions receiving federal funds is illegal. The letter was sent by the Obama administration Department of Justice's civil rights division and the Department of Education's office for civil rights. The point of the letter was, accord- ing to then-Secretary of Education Arne Duncan, to provide "information on how schools and districts can meet their legal obligations to administer student discipline without discrimina- tion on race, color, or national origin." Sounds reasonable enough. But a closer look reveals that these were far more than guidelines. Behind the scenes, the Obama administration's De- partment of Education used the DCL to aggressively launch investigations to assure that school districts implement- ed these guidelines, which constituted a highly questionable departure from what civil rights law requires. The DCL informed school officials that they would be investigating more than disciplinary policies applied vari- ably across racial lines. Now, uniform- ly constructed and applied disciplinary policies would be viewed as noncom- pliant if they produce disparate results. One doesn't need to be a constitu- tional or civil rights law scholar to see this as a problem. And, in fact, when current Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas was as- sistant secretary for civil rights at the Department of Education in 1981, his guidelines were quite clear that dis- crimination constituted different rules or different application of those rules between races — not uniform rules and applications that produce dispa- rate results. The Obama administration's DCL guidelines overturned and replaced Thomas' guidelines. As documented by scholar Max Eden of the Manhattan Institute, the whole point was to change the role of the Department of Education's office for civil rights from an entity that mon- itors compliance with the law to an en- tity that decides what policies and pro- cedures school administrators should be following — and to find them non- compliant if out of line. Given that we're talking about the threat of cutting off federal funds, can there be any question that public school officials became more interested in the wants of federal government than what the best policies were locally? According to Eden, from 2009 to 2017, "at least 350 school districts — serving nearly 10 million children, or about one-fifth of all public elementa- ry and secondary schools students in the U.S. — were investigated for the ex- press purpose of coercing districts into changing their disciplinary policies." Eden continues, "According to (then-Secretary of Education) Dun- can, societal ills such as poverty, bro- ken families, and neighborhood crime have little effect on student behavior. Rather, racism among teachers and ad- ministrators is responsible for the fact that black students are more than three times as likely as white students to be suspended." President Trump's Department of Education's office for civil rights should withdraw and rescind this 2014 Dear Colleague Letter. Can it really be that hard to appreci- ate that all discipline problems of black children may not be rooted in racism? Every child is unique. Personal chal- lenges can only be handled personal- ly and intimately, and thus should only involve local school officials, the child, parents and their supportive commu- nity. At minimum, let's restore the De- partment of Education's civil rights job to what it should be — monitoring compliance with the law instead of de- ciding how local educators should run their schools. More local flexibility and mobility through vouchers or other parental choice platforms may be exactly what students need, not an overhaul of our entire public schooling apparatus. Star Parker is an author and presi- dent of CURE, Center for Urban Renew- al and Education. Contact her at www. urbancure.org. The Weekly by Alden Heuring Morality for squares The popular television series Spongebob Squarepants is certain- ly not known for its educational value. But having recently been exposed to some of the early ep- isodes, I couldn't help but notice a distinct moral pattern in the sto- ries that caught my interest. So, of course, I wanted to share it. Let's look at the episode "Bub- bles" as an example. "Bubbles" follows a very simple plot line. Spongebob sets up a stand to sell bubble wands and bubble blow- ing lessons. Patrick buys in (with a quarter he borrowed from his pal, Spongebob) and the two start blowing bubbles. This irritates their neighbor Squidward, who is trying to play clarinet. He lobs some verbal abuse, attempts to blow a better bubble than Spongebob and Pat- rick to show them up, fails, and when he finally succeeds (by steal- ing Spongebob's method and tak- ing the credit for himself ), the bubble carries him and his house high into the sky before popping. Meanwhile, Spongebob and Pat- rick spend this entire time encour- aging and cheering Squidward on in his selfish struggles, because they're just happy that he's partic- ipating with them. Watching this episode, the mor- al allegory is almost painfully ob- vious. Spongebob is a type of our merciful God, drawing others in- to his joyous existence by offer- ing bubble wands and bubble les- sons. Patrick is the converted be- liever, buying into Spongebob's message and sharing abundantly in his bubble-blowing life. Sponge- bob and Patrick offer this same life to Squidward, who rejects the Good News of bubbles, spends the entire episode thwarting himself, and ultimately is crushed under the weight of his own selfish choic- es (symbolized by the giant, an- gry bubble he blew just to prove his neighbors wrong), despite Sponge- bob and Patrick's best efforts to help him join the fun. In this 15 -minute allegory, we see a clear path for ourselves to an abundant life. We too are called to share in our neighbor's joys and strivings, even if they seem sil- ly from our perspective. If you'll pardon the cheap alliterative im- agery: we want to be a participat- ing Patrick, not a sneering Squid- ward. And that's my soapbox for this week. Have a great one!

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of South Gibson Star-Times - September 18, 2018