The South Gibson Star-Times serves the towns of Haubstadt, Owensville and Fort Branch.
Issue link: https://www.ifoldsflip.com/i/1028717
A-6 Local Tuesday, September 18, 2018 South Gibson Star-Times Richard's Furniture & Mattress Richard's Mattress Warehouse 108 N. MaiN St., PriNcetoN, iN 521 Grave St., Patoka, iN 812-385-3855 812-779-2300 Both Stores Open: Mon-Sat, 10am-5pm FAMILY Owned & OperAted Richard's Retirement Sale SAVE up to 50% STORE CLOSING! Huge Inventory! No Reasonable Offer Refused! MUST BE SACRIFICED! 20% OFF No Reasonable Offer Refused! EVERY ITEM IN STORE! SPECIAL! * $ 669 King Size Mattress with matching foundation $ 389 Reg. Price *limited quantities LIMITED TIME IF YOU DIDN'T BUY IT AT RICHARD'S, YOU PROBABLY PAID TOO MUCH! QUITTING BUSINESS PRINCETON LOCATION at our We can get you approved! Credit Problems? Divorced? Bankrupt? HOSKINS Continued from page 1 Woman arrested on OWI charges at Marathon station An early morning fill up led to charges of operating while intoxicated Sept. 14 at the Marathon Fastbreak in Fort Branch. According to a Gibson County Sheriff's report, at 9:11 a.m., Gibson County Central Dispatch received a report of a possible intox- icated driver at the gas sta- tion. Fort Branch Chief Rick Sides observed a maroon 2011 Kia pull out of the lot and onto U.S. 41. He attempted a traf- fic stop, however, accord- ing to the report, the vehi- cle did not stop until near Dead Man's Curve. At that point, Deputy Jennifer Loesch and Dep- uty U.B. Smith arrived on scene and began a road- side DUI investigation that resulted in the driver, 30 -year-old Ruth Bird, of LaGrange, Ky., being tak- en into custody and trans- ported to the Gibson Coun- ty Jail. Upon arriving at the jail, Bird was charged with Operating a Vehicle While Intoxicated. Accident leads to OWI arrest An accident Sept. 11 led to the arrest of a 52-year- old man on charges of oper- ating a vehicle while intoxi- cated, among other charg- es, according to a Gibson County Sheriff's Office re- port. According to the release, at 2:27 p.m., Gibson Coun- ty Central Dispatch re- ceived a report of a single vehicle accident at the in- tersection of Salem Lane and Ind. 56, involving a ma- roon Toyota Corolla. Sergeant Bruce Vano- ven was dispatched to the scene, and upon arriv- ing, began an investiga- tion into the accident. Ac- cording to the accident re- port, 52-year-old Anthony Sutherland, the driver of the vehicle, appeared too intoxicated to accurate- ly perform the test. Upon speaking with Sutherland, Sgt. Vanoven detected the strong odor of alcohol com- ing from the driver and be- gan a roadside investiga- tion. A portable breath test put his blood alcohol level at .332. Sutherland was taken in- to custody and transported to the Gibson County Jail, where he was issued cita- tions for Failure To Stop at a Stop Sign and Operating a Vehicle Without a License in His Possession. He was also charged with Operat- ing a Motor Vehicle With- out Financial Responsibil- ity with a prior conviction and Operating a Vehicle While Intoxicated. Assisting Sgt. Vanoven in his investigation was Deputy Austin Farrington. Ruth Bird Anthony Sutherland The Viking-style drinking gear was in view of the door and in seeing it, Trina Fla- nary said during her testi- mony she believed she was seeing a bong, which is a tool used to smoke marijuana. "We were asked to keep an eye out for anything unusu- al," she said on the stand. "Steve said he was trying to turn this into a family place." She asked her husband to contact Steve Hess. Schafer said he was roused again 45 minutes after the first knock to talk to Steven Hess. "He said we needed to cool it with the pot, and he was tired of people coming in and out of the hotel. He said someone had reported a bong." Hoskins and his girlfriend left. "Everyone left in a good mood, excited to celebrate his birthday the next day," Schafer said. Overnight, blizzard-like conditions swept through the county. Schafer left the hotel room at 4 a.m. to breakfast with his father, driving at a snail's pace through the snow and ice, he said. A fter breakfast with his fa- ther, he received a call from his girlfriend saying Mari- on Hess had walked into her room and told her to leave for violating the "no drug" policy. Trying to think of why management would be- lieve they had drugs, Scha- fer said he remembered the drinking horn and believed it might have been mistaken for a bong. He called Hoskins, and arranged to pick him and the drinking horn up from Hoskins' home. "He thought it was ridicu- lous," Schafer said about the drinking horn being mistak- en for paraphernalia. "We were laughing, and thought it would be easy to clear up." Just before 8 a.m., they knocked on the door of the locked manager's office and Marion Hess answered the door. Marion Hess clutched a handkerchief trembling in front of her mouth as she watched the video of her hus- band's death for the first time from the witness stand. It was the first time, she said, because she had never wanted to see it. In a slight German ac- cent, she explained her hus- band, Steve Hess, a vet, brought her from Germany and they'd been married al- most 29 years, but only man- aged The Diplomat for a little over a year at the time of the shooting. Before that, they had lived in the motel. Her husband had told her about the complaints and re- port of drugs. She said she knocked twice before enter- ing the room and seeing Caris- sa Hoskins in bed, telling her she needed to leave by 11 a.m. because the occupants had vi- olated the no drug policy. When the two young men tapped on the glass just be- fore 8 a.m. that morning, she told her husband he could stay in their apartment. "I told Steve 'I got this,'" she said. From there, she remem- bered Hoskins slamming his drinking horn on the desk. "He said, 'This was not an effing bong, it was a drinking glass'...I was the only one in office, it felt threatening," she said. She said she picked up a bat made by a friend, some- thing she said she's never had to use. "We don't believe in guns...I'm a little wom- an," she said about why she picked up the bat. She said she told Hoskins he needed to leave because he was not on the room rental agree- ment. Marion Hess said her hus- band heard the argument and came from their apartment. "He said, 'No one talks to my wife like that,'" she said, adding when he arrived, she put the bat down. She remembered her hus- band telling the men to leave, and her husband pushing Hoskins outside. She fol- lowed her husband out the door. "He didn't shove him hard. He didn't shove him hard," she would tell Walton under the defense's cross-exami- nation. She would estimate her husband's weight at 240 pounds. "I'm a hundred pounds with two guys in the office. Would I have the right to shoot somebody? " she asked Walton. Walton asked why she fol- lowed her husband out the door. "I've always been protec- tive of my husband. I know he's a man. But I try to keep him out of trouble. So he doesn't do something he'll re- gret. I've always succeeded." "I was right next to Steve... he shot Steve once, and then shot him again." She said the first time nothing came out. In cross examination, Wal- ton would ask Mrs. Hess if the click she believed was the gun not firing could have been the safety clicking off. She said it could have been. "I saw Steve falling to the ground. They were standing there. I said 'Is no one going to call the effing 9 -1-1? ' And it didn't look like anyone was going to, and I was trying to hold my husband's chest and I called the 9 -1-1," she said. She said Schafer told Hoskins to put the gun down, and after he did, he said it was self-defense. "I said it wasn't self-de- fense," she said. In cross examination, she would elaborate. ".. they were just stand- ing there smirking like huh- hunh." The prosecution asked how the loss of her husband affected her life. "I live a nightmare every single day," she said. Joseph Flanary remem- bered what Marion Hess was like moments after the shooting. "Next thing I remember, I came back to bed with the kids, and Marion opened door and said, 'He shot Steve; he shot Steve; he shot Steve.' Steve was laying in gravel, he was blue and purple. Marion was there, she was an abso- lute wreck," Flanary said. Schafer's memories dif- fered in some ways from Mar- ion Hess'. He said he had been cor- dial. "I said, 'Good morning, I think there's been misun- derstanding,' as we're walk- ing in," he said, adding he believed she may not have heard him, and was yelling quickly after they entered and gesturing to the no-drug policy. He remembered Hoskins saying "Does this look like a bong to you? " in a more neu- tral tone than Marion Hess had described. He said Marion Hess told him he had to respect her and "get the hell out of there." Schafer said he felt threat- ened and bewildered. "I didn't know why the situ- ation would keep escalating," he said. According to Schafer, Ste- ven Hess came across the counter at Hoskins. He said Hess told them to leave, and told Hoskins to stop talking. Hoskins told Hess that he would leave the property, but it was his first amendment right to say what he wanted. "Rules are very impor- tant—rights are very impor- tant to Christian," Schafer said in cross-examination. Schafer said that Hess was enraged by the reply. "He said something like he'd show Christian his first amendment rights and kick his ass." Then Steven Hess pushed Hoskins out the door, Scha- fer said, adding he was sur- prised his friend stayed on his feet. He said he heard Hoskins tell Hess to get back, heard Hess curse, and could tell Hoskins had raised his weap- on. He said he saw Hess charge or lunge toward the weapon. Hoskins fired a 9 mm shot that, on the video, travels through Steven Hess, pass- es approximately three feet in front of Marion Hess, then through a window. Schafer said afterwards he and Hoskins called 9 -1-1, and encouraged Marion Hess to put pressure on the wound, but she didn't want help from them. Walton played the 9 -1-1 call. In it, Schafer reported an assault at The Diplomat. The dispatcher asked if "the victim" was still breath- ing. Schafer responded he was. Walton asked him about that comment. Schafer said the victim he was referring to that was still breathing was not Ste- ven Hess. He said the victim he re- ferred to was his friend. When Hoskins took the stand, Walton asked Hoskins to describe the effect seven months in jail had on him. In an explanation during an objection, Walton said that Hoskins had body trem- ors, fast talking, repetitive tasking issues as a result of incarceration, and he said he wanted the jury to under- stand that, because he didn't want the jury to see his cli- ent as robotic and unaffected. Hoskins did speak quick- ly and the microphone had difficulty amplifying his tes- timony. Several times, Walton asked his client to slow down and speak up for the jury. Hoskins said he'd learned shooting as a child from his father and grandfather. He said he was fearful and uncomfortable when Marion Hess picked up the bat, and when Steven Hess yelled and pointed at him. He remembered telling Steven Hess it was his first amendment right to have free speech, he said. He described the push out the door by Ste- ven Hess as like being hit by a vehicle, and said, though he stayed on his feet, he was afraid of slipping on the ice, and it knocked his glasses askew. He described Hess as rush- ing at him and said he'd be- lieved drawing the weapon would stop the entire situa- tion. He said he felt turning his back on Hess would have been a bad idea, and said Hess was reaching for the gun when he fired. Prosecutor Mike Co- chren asked Hoskins why he wouldn't be able to get away from a much larger, and pre- sumably slower person. "Weight has very little to do with speed," Hoskins said. Cochren asked why he aimed for center mass. "Isn't that more likely to kill? " Cochren said. "No. A head shot is more likely to kill," Hoskins said. Cochren also questioned Hoskins' description of be- ing pushed as similar to be- ing hit by a vehicle. Walton played Hoskins' 9 - 1-1 call, and during the call, Hoskins reports an assault in which he used his firearm. Hoskins identified himself, during the recording of the 9 - 1-1 call, as yelling "put pres- sure on it." Addressing the jury, Dep- uty Prosecutor Abigail Cox pointed to the evidence of the video. "It's unusual to have a case, where there's no dispute of who shot," she said. "That part is very clear." She and Cochren would stress that Hess had no weapon. "Let's not forget that Mr. Hess is the victim here," Co- chren said. "What is reason- able force? ... I would contend his actions are not reasonable given the situation." Cochren said narrowing to the time of the shot had been a focal point for the case, but there was a larger context to consider. "There were drugs in the room. Mr. Hoskins contrib- uted to an escalated situa- tion...had he not had to get the last word in, none of this would have happened," Co- chren said, adding Hoskins had been practicing shoot- ing for years. "It was a big mo- ment in his life, a moment he trained for." Walton would build the self-defense case on the weapon Marion Hess had— the bat—the closeness of Steven Hess when Hoskins shot, saying that it was with- in 20 feet—arguing it was close enough to inflict seri- ous harm. He invited to the stand self- defense expert Guy Minnis, a former Evansville Police Offi- cer, who testified to the beat- ing deaths he'd seen on duty. Walton stressed Hess' weight advantage of 100 pounds, describing his cli- ent as "a young man no big- ger than a bar of soap after a week's bath." He demonstrated to the ju- ry the up-and-down wobble of the weapon as seen on the vid- eo, re-enacting it in his clos- ing arguments, and calling the legal description of self- defense versus murder the gospel the jury would have to rely on for the decision, call- ing it the kryptonite to the murder charge. He raised his voice, asking the jury if they thought his client would have the same treatment if he were a police officer. He zoomed in on the video to a shot of what he called the fear on his client's face. Walton said he legally car- ries a weapon every day. "I want to go home when (expletive) goes bad," he said. "To think that he trained for this day is absolutely im- plausible." Hoskins would have served a minimum of 60 years in jail if convicted of murder—the weight of having his client's future in his hands was heavy since he took the case, Wal- ton said, after leaving the courtroom. He also said that as a per- son that carries a weapon, he felt the stakes were high. In his closing argument, he told jurors they would decide whether people could defend themselves from an attack in Gibson County. Cochren, for the prosecu- tion, also said in his closing argument, jurors would set a precedent, deciding whether every fistfight could turn into a case of deadly force. As for Hoskins, during his testimony, he said if he could, he would not have gone to the hotel that morning. In the ex- act same circumstance, to protect himself, however, he said he would shoot again. "You told Detective Bal- lard every shot counts and you were glad to be able to do what you did," Cochren said in cross examination. "I don't recall saying glad," said Hoskins.

